The Witcher - Review @ ComputerGames.ro

magerette

Hedgewitch
Joined
October 18, 2006
Messages
7,834
ComputerGames.ro posts their detailed review of CDProjekt's recently released cRPG, The Witcher, giving it a score of 86/100:
True, The Witcher isn’t the first RPG to offer choices and consequences that influence the storyline, but in this case they are faithful to one of the distinctive features of Andrzej Sapkowski’s fantasy universe...: there are no “good” and “bad” characters; you will always have to choose the lesser of two evils. Moreover, the consequences of your choices won’t become apparent right away, but after a few more hours of playtime, sometimes even stretching between acts. I have to admit that I was skeptical when I first heard about this choices & consequences deal, thinking it was just a PR gimmick (and I’m sure that I wasn’t the only one).
Fortunately, I was wrong and CD Projeckt stayed true to their word. I think I clocked at least 80 hours of playtime with The Witcher, mostly because I replayed large segments of it in order to see what other paths the story could have taken. By their very nature, some choices will probably allow you to see, at least generally speaking, what the consequences will be, but others will have surprising results.
This is one of the main novelties in The Witcher: unlike other RPGs, you can’t choose between A and B knowing for certain that you will end up at C or D. You will do so either because you will try to relate to what the developers wanted you to experience and say that “well, the other option wasn’t important, and even if it was, I can replay the game” or depending on how you want Geralt to evolve during the story. For instance, in Gothic 3 things were simple: the orcs were “bad”, so if you wanted to be an "evil" character, you sided with the orcs. If you wanted a “good” character, you sided with the human population. In The Witcher there are far more nuances: are the elves freedom fighters or can they be considered terrorists, in the modern sense of the word? Will I stay neutral or side with the humans, among which I have so many friends? This gives the game an extremely high replay value, even for an RPG.
...Thus, in many ways, The Witcher is the game which probably a lot [of] RPG fans hoped for. The story, atmosphere, the relationship between choices and consequences, the graphics, musical score and the non-linear nature of some quests clearly define it as a reference RPG for years to come. And there are also some interesting innovations, like the character development tree and the combat system. But what prevents The Witcher from entering the gallery of truly great titles is what pretty much plagues other diamonds in the rough: lots of crashes, long and frequent loading times as well as an artificially limited freedom of movement.
More information.
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
7,834
I agree with the load times, but not with the crashes. Haven't had one yet personally. AFAIC this game is the most stable that I've bought in many months. Need for Speed Pro Street (my only other recently purchased title) is less stable than The Witcher!

Not sure what he means by "artificially limited freedom of movement." Isn't the whole game 'artificial?' ;)

... I think I know what he means, but the limited movement (if he is talking about not jumping or inability to go anywhere you want) is not high on my list of personal requirements.
 
Joined
Oct 20, 2006
Messages
1,081
Location
Midwest, USA
Yeah, he made a pretty big gripe out of not being able to run or jump in one of the earlier pages of the review, suggesting it would have been less irritating if things were fenced off with large obstructions so you knew you couldn't go there (??)-but he still managed to play the game for 80 hours so he managed to adapt. ;)

I don't know what he means about crashes either--I haven't had any so far through Act 4--maybe it's a Vista thing. The load times are getting seriously distracting though, so I'm waiting for the patch--well, when I can keep myself from playing...:)
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
7,834
I have only had one crash when I first installed it and that I found out was a driver issue on my rig. Since then not a crash. And it was the sound drivers at fault, so maybe he needed to make some changes?
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
2,384
Location
Missouri USA
I've had crashes: several times while I'm exiting from the game, and twice in chapter changes (was annoying when I finally beat the Beast, and it crashed).

I guess the game might have some problems when unloading lots of information from memory. I'm on XP.
 
Joined
Oct 23, 2006
Messages
585
Location
Serbia
I've had crashes: several times while I'm exiting from the game, and twice in chapter changes (was annoying when I finally beat the Beast, and it crashed).

I guess the game might have some problems when unloading lots of information from memory. I'm on XP.

Oh,.. now that you mentioned it, yeah, my game crashes every time I exit. But I never really thought of it as being a 'crash', because I was intentionally exiting the game anyhow. I just get that familiar XP error message that "the Witcher has encountered a problem and needs to close." But I've never had it crash on me while playing the game.
 
Joined
Oct 20, 2006
Messages
1,081
Location
Midwest, USA
I am seriously slacking off playing the Witcher lately, I have no guarantee that saves will work with 1.2 and through all the loading it just killing the game for me. :(
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
2,772
Tends to crash on saving for me but apart from that excellent game so far.
 
Joined
Oct 26, 2006
Messages
2,080
Location
UK
I am seriously slacking off playing the Witcher lately, I have no guarantee that saves will work with 1.2 and through all the loading it just killing the game for me. :(

Never thought about that one but you're right - I would hate to get halfway through the game or more and then find out I have to start over. My allowable time for games being what it is, I rarely play through a game more than once, no matter how good it is.

I've been engrossed in Need for Speed Pro Street for the past few days, so I might just wait for the patch like you.
 
Joined
Oct 20, 2006
Messages
1,081
Location
Midwest, USA
I've had numerous crashes, but only in certain areas. And looking about the net it seems that this is not isolated to just vista, as some have claimed. That aside there are a number of other niggles - all interface/gameplay related - such as auto-sheathing of weapons at inopportune times, not being able to draw your sword in "safe" areas etc This bugs the hell out of me, since monsters can pop up quickly even in "safe" areas. That's not to say the game is not excellent, just that it has flaws/issues and people should recognize those and not put it on a pedestal a la Oblivion.
 
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
2,137
Location
Cape Town, South Africa
Yeah, surprise attacks often don't work, as the game performs the one thing I hate; a Cut Scene/ Dialogue right before the fight. Then you have your sword sheathed, and usually they don't!! grrrr.
 
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
12,806
Location
Australia
That bugged the heck outta me too at first, but then I realized that Geralt draws his weapon so stinking fast it didn't matter much. Usually I have my weapon ready to go and even if they strike first he usually parries the blow. Not trying to defend that aspect because I think it's stupid too, but at least it's not a big deal.
 
Joined
Oct 20, 2006
Messages
1,081
Location
Midwest, USA
Forced Sheathing, forced cutscenes and stupid bell that sounds that won't allpw you to draw your weapon, irritate the hell out of me too. :shakefist:
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
2,772
I have had a few crashes doing loading scenes. Nothing that I have cursed to much over though.

One thing I have found irritating though was when fighting in cities and you get guards or civilians to help and they are "blue", its quite easy to click on them by mistake and then they turn red and attack you.

Otherwise, a really great game. Not had such a good game experience since I played Morrowind.
 
Joined
Aug 30, 2007
Messages
207
Location
Copenhagen, Denmark
True, the engine seems rather limited in it's design of the hitbox area of the NPCs and even loot/objects you need to pick up.
This forces you constantly to either shift your camera view, change your position or both, yet it's so good, I keep plugging away at this game. :)

One thing I don't understand about these smaller independent developers is why they don't get more help from their fans, when they see themselves falling behind, it's totally bizarre and as if they don't even think of this.
As an example all Cd Projekt had to do was have a contest of fan modders for the top 10 best NPC skins and boom they would have had access to 100s of choices, with just offering a little credit to the authors.
Additionally they must have had 100s if not 1000s of fans in Poland willing to help with testing, as PB could have done with G3 and all the fans in Germany.
I really don't see how independents are going to be able to exist without the help of fans.
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
2,772
Good point.

This is totally nit-picky I know, but the lack of variety in modeling doesn't just end with the NPCs. Have you noticed how many guards and soldiers carry around a 'witcher's steel sword?' The only difference is that it's strapped to their sides instead of on their backs.
I personally feel that a high quality Witcher's sword should look unique and apart from any other weapons.
 
Joined
Oct 20, 2006
Messages
1,081
Location
Midwest, USA
Additionally they must have had 100s if not 1000s of fans in Poland willing to help with testing, as PB could have done with G3 and all the fans in Germany.

Just one minor nitpick here: fans don't (necessarily) make good beta testers.

Still, though, I agree - there's no reason game developers shouldn't ask fans for help, they just shouldn't expect to get 1000's of professional models/whatever (but rather 1, 2 or 5).
 
Joined
Oct 23, 2006
Messages
585
Location
Serbia
The game crashes for me during The Beast encounter. First time it was just at the cut scene upon exiting the cave. NOW, it happens every time I kill The Beast and get attacked by the villagers. The user interface just disappears and the screen freezes. First time I had to reboot to even get my computer back. Second time I was able to close the game using Task Manager.

Yes, I have the latest drivers.
 
Joined
Dec 3, 2007
Messages
171
Location
Austin, Texas
Eliaurese post some system specs and maybe someone could help you sort out what the cause is.
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
2,384
Location
Missouri USA
Back
Top Bottom