RPGWatch Forums

RPGWatch Forums (http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/index.php)
-   News Comments (http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   Gothic 3 - Review @ PC Gameplay (http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1155)

Gorath January 19th, 2007 13:18

Gothic 3 - Review @ PC Gameplay
 
Belgian print mag PC Gameplay had a very detailed review of Piranha Bytes´ RPG in their november issue. Unfortunately we can´t post the whole thing. Especially the comparisons to Oblivion are an interesting read.
Here are a few translated excerpts:

Quote:

ITíS ALIVE! ALIVE!
The game world is full of life, something Gothic always had. The inhabitants have a job which can vary: woodcutter, blacksmith, shop owner. In the evening they are eating wild boar around a campfire and at night the all go to sleep. Even the animals have a daily routine: searching for a prey during day, sleeping at night. There is a lot of interaction with the surroundings, you can use a smithís anvil, an alchemist bench or a pan at a campfire which gives a bonus to the food you carry in your inventory (which by the way is limitless). You do have tight behaviour rules you have to follow. Walking around with a unsheathed sword is considered hostile, walking into another manís house is rude and stealing is out of the question. If you get caught, guards will be alerted and the person in question will never talk to you again. If you decide to give a human or orc the finishing blow youíd better make sure there are no witnesses […]. In Gothic 3 you have a reputation which differs in each city and town. To get a better reputation youíll need to get on the good side of a lot of important people by doing quests. If you address a person youíll notice all dialogs are spoken, which is in contrast to Oblivion. Unfortunately the quests are often the same as the previous one (slit this throat, get that item). Oblivion preformed better on this part. Every quest had a short story, remember the painting, dream world or Dark Brotherhood quests? The quests in Gothic 3 are more of the same.
Quote:

[…] This makes Gothic 3 a difficult game to rate. Itís the most accessible in the series, and performs in some areas better than Oblivion. Oblivion is what you get when you further develop Morrowind for the mainstream audience, and Gothic 3 is what you get when you further develop Morrowind for the RPG fanatic. Unfortunately, the Gothic 3 apple has a dirty worm in it. So what to do, I feel like beating up the publisher because they released the game to early, and give the developer a bonus because the gameplay is good. Ultimately we decided to deduct six point from the gameplay because of the bugs. If an all-solving-patch is ever released, the final score will get another six points. With those extra point Gothic 3 will ascend into the excellence regions beside Oblivion, were it actually belongs.
The score is 84%. Thanks EDV! :) More information.

Acleacius January 19th, 2007 13:18

Nice, thanks Gorath. :)

Those silly Belgians don't they know only vixens in platemail should be on covers. ;)

txa1265 January 19th, 2007 15:52

I like the way the reviewer brings Oblivion in as a fairly neutral comparison point - rather than just putting up Oblivion as perfection as happens in many reviews it takes individual points of merit to contrast.

titus January 19th, 2007 16:38

I am from belgian and I read it the magazien from time to time. They always have good and interesting reviews and previews. And now they proof that they know how to recognize a good game, and still be fair of the flaws

Dajjer January 20th, 2007 08:12

The last paragraph sums up my view for the game. Almost. The took out climbing and I don't think that can be fixed with a patch. Still, because of all the problems, I too would rate this game somewhere in the mid 80s.


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 14:31.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright by RPGWatch