Things you would change?
View Single Post
Things you would change?
December 7th, 2008, 05:16
Okay, I finally finished the game last week. Really the best game I've probably ever played - or at least on par with Gothic and Gothic II. Anyway, I want to start one of those constructive criticism threads - what would you change about the game if you could… Or… what would you like to see different in the sequel?
I know we'll get a few haters on here, but hopefully we can keep it fairly realistic.
1) For god's sake, if I want to keep my weapon out, let me keep my weapon out!!! Don't sheath it for me every 5 seconds and/or when I stop to pluck a flower petal.
2) More cutscenes for non-critical moments to increase narrative impact - What I mean is, there were some great moments in the game that were sort of neutralized by keeping it within the actual playing engine Example:
After freeing Adda of the curse for the second time, she's suddenly standing there with her tiara on, commenting on how cold she is. Then the game allows you control again JUST TO LEAVE THE CRYPT while she saunters along in her nightie like she's leading you to bed - it's just weird and ruins the realism and impact. Why not skip that unnecessary movement and replace it with a brief cutscene showing Geralt carrying poor, shivering, naked Adda out of the crypt and then hand her over to Velerad, who wraps her up in his coat?
That's just an example, but there were plenty of other moments that would have raised the bar in the storytelling even more if they had created it more like a movie. I know some people complained about the game being too linear as it is, but they can just go play Mount & Blade.
3) More variation of character models. Yeah, the EE gave them more color choices, whoop-de-doo
4) More contextual appearances for the main characters - Example
At the beginning of Chapter III Geralt awakens in Triss' bed after being seriously injured. Can somebody tell me why he's still in full armor? Couldn't he at least be in the same model as the game's beginning and then you can go to her wardrobe and find your equipment there?
Such is a very minor thing, but would be a little more realistic that way, which in turns fleshes out the storytelling that much more. Same for Triss and others - You're telling me that the wealthiest sorcerer in Vizima only has two outfits?
5) More weapons variatons - One thing I loved about the Gothic series was the endless assortment of weapons to choose from, and they were cool looking. There really weren't many choices in TW. There were two or three special swords available but they didn't 'fit' Geralt's look, e.g.the scimitar that is made available near the end of the game. I ended up using my heavily upgraded Witcher's sword throughout.
6) Fewer enemies in some locations. The swamp cemetery was just crawling with drowners - you couldn't possibly kill all of them and it got old really quick. Plus when you were tired of fighting them and simply wanted to get questing done, you couldn't because the game wouldn't let you enter another location until combat mode switches off. That was really annoying.
7) Get rid of the spooky beastie and critter sound effects in human controlled areas (like refugee caves and the like). The growling and grunting and heartbeat sound effects are great for a monster infested crypt, but it just doesn't fit in EVERY cave or crypt.
8) Is there any building in the Northern Kingdoms that doesn't have a 20' high ceiling? How is that even possible after looking like such a small hut on the outside?
9) More sensible and varied house layouts. Every house you enter leaves you the option of either going up or down. Incidentally, why do so many people have unused, monster infested basements?
10) Constantly being kicked out of dialogue, or having to wait until an NPC finished their animation before being able to talk again.
Those are my biggest complaints, and every one of those is pretty minor when you consider the overall product. So what does everyone else think?….
..& so they take the fiction all out of the Jabberwock & I recognize & accept him as a fact. - Mark Twain, May 30, 1880
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Midwest, USA
View Public Profile
Send a private message to Jabberwocky
Find More Posts by Jabberwocky