Originally Posted by GothicGothicness
Oblivion 93% - Gothic II 62% ? PCGamer UK 0%

It's almost exactly how I would score those two games as well, so it's an opinion. Gothic just doesn't do it for many, many players. I'm a hardcore crpg'er too, so it's not that. As a general rule, I prefer games that were developed by people who speak English as their primary/only language. English is a very difficult language to master and something is always lost in translation. I would imagine most folks prefer games that are developed in their native language, although there are several people at the Watch who play the English versions of games even if there is a native version available.