Originally Posted by Guybrush
Actually G3 wasn't as Redundant as most other games. Its still a better game than for example, Fable.

I agree, although it's pretty easy to be better than Fable.

Despite all its flaws, Gothic 3 is still one of my favorite recent crpgs.

1. Risen
2. The Witcher
3. Gothic 3

….would probably be my favorite *recent* RPGs, but there isn't much that separates them.