Originally Posted by Paul 
I would give it to Witcher 2, but NV is amazing RPG too, so I can not be dissapointed. I am just glad Dragon Age 2 did not win..
That's what I've planned to say… You've beat me.
The real questioon here would be how DA2 got nominated in the first place and where is DX:HR since they don't care what year a game was released?
EDIT:
GOTY is Portal 2… I admit I didn't play that one. Any input is it really better than FO:NV and TW2?