Originally Posted by DArtagnan
I'd give it 10/10 personally.
I agree, though, that the skill system hurts longevity - but the way they've implemented Inferno mode and how the AH works means there are other reasons to keep playing for a very long time.
But, even though I disagree with Blizzard about some things, I have to say they've executed what they set out to do - perfectly.
I've played this 60 hours almost non-stop since I got it, and that means it triggered something that only happens to me every 5 years or so.