Originally Posted by JDR13
A friend of mine was stuck in that same situation. He eventually overcame it by going into one of the huts so that Garcia and his men had to attack one at a time. Once you kill Garcia, the villagers should stop being aggro.

I managed to kill Garcia in his hut, but some of the others saw me and then everyone went hostile. I have a minion with me, but they did not last long. I'll have to keep on trying I guess.