Originally Posted by JDR13 
…
Just being an open-world game doesn't mean Bethesda has the ability to make a Stalker title that would feel like a worthy sequel. Stalker's strongest aspect was its atmosphere, and it wasn't remotely similar to anything Bethesda has done.
+1
Nothing I have seen from Bethesda implies that they could create the same atmosphere, but I wouldn't mind to be proven wrong.
C