Originally Posted by JDR13
No, that's an example of a game that definitely needs voice acting. Too bad that didn't save it from being a mediocre series anyways.
Eh? I'm one of the biggest defenders of FO3 around here, but the voice acting was mostly terrible.
Torment is obviously not a typical game and would be an extreme example. There's probably only a handful of games ever made that have that much text.
As far as immersion is concerned, sometimes it helps, sometimes it doesn't. It's always going to be one of those subjective things.