Dissapointed that Dark Souls ranked so high. Why anyone would spend money on that drivel is beyond me.
Regarding ME3: I bought ME1
layed it quite some time, but did not finish, because it felt so contrived. Bought ME2: played 5 hours and shelved it - not an RPG. ME3: no money from me.
Can't see why Kingdoms of Amalur ranked so low (and GoT didn't even made the list), because it actually was an RPG.
X-Com is a wonderful game, but it really should't have been on the list.