Originally Posted by joxer 
Sorry but in my case it delivered completely except the too easy final fight but that was patched soon. Should I mention that I've replayed it already because it was more than enjoyable?
Good you found it enjoyable enough to play more than once good for you. I found no reason to make myself play it again.
As for there game of the year I have no opinion about it so I can't say. I never played Legend of Grimrock doubt I ever will.
All I got from last year was it was a bad year for Rpg's.