Originally Posted by Brother None
Reviewed it way back when. In hindsight, I actually think I went too easy on it in that review. It's not all that good. It's not terrible, I didn't hate it, apart from some design decisions which I did honestly loathe (quick-event traps, killcam), but is there any one thing it was good enough at for an award? Sound, graphics, story, character system? Not really. And overall can't say I considered it for RPGotY at all.

Yet you guys thought KoA was the 2nd best RPG of 2012? Ok.

Originally Posted by Brother None
and I know at least one other staff member (WUE) played it.

Ah.. so at least two people at GB played it. Well that's reassuring.