Originally Posted by Sir_Brennus 
I think both are vastly inferior to pt. 3 "Wrath of Nikademus". Easily the biggest and best of them all. Very atmospheric text descriptions there.
I never got to play P3 (an abbreviation that now only you and I understand), but reviews of the time criticized its much more granular combat system, where health was tracked for individual limbs, etc. It certainly
looks like a mess.