Originally Posted by Corwin
How about both!!

Haha, going all the way I see. How bout this: we have two types of review per game.

1) Simplified and brief, fits on 1 page and has a score.
For people who can't be bothered with reading everything (OH NOES!! REEDING IS TEH HARD!11!)

2) Dissertation style,spanning MANY pages, completely comprehensive and ends with a summary. No score.

Why should we make so much effort to make two similar reviews in different styles? So that we can log the IP of people (1), locate them and bash them over the head with a dictionary.