Originally Posted by Acleacius
Well maybe for you, but so far you haven't provided any substantial reasoning for your position, which was the point I was trying to make, is not a good idea for the community, imo.

I wasn't of the opinion that the game shouldn't be covered here. I was merely stating that folks who thought that had some amount of reasonable defense in the fact that the game is a shooter and that the focus of the site is RPG. It isn't even a matter of trying to define RPG's and say that the Deep-Shadows stuff doesn't belong here due to the balance of RPG-to-shooter being off. Bioshock has a lineage in shooters with RPG elements, but it is a shooter.