|
Your donations keep RPGWatch running!
RPGWatch Forums » Games » Indie RPG » Tactica: Maiden of Faith » Story Characters vs Player Made Characters

View Poll Results - Do you prefer story character or to create you own ones?

Yes, I only want my own characters 8 21.05%
No, I want only story characters 10 26.32%
I want both story and my own characters. 15 39.47%
Other ( Please specify in the thread) 5 13.16%
Voters: 38. You may not vote on this poll

Default Story Characters vs Player Made Characters

September 5th, 2009, 10:42
I am having a kind of dilema about this. To have story characters in the group is kind of necesarry for the game, but I also think it is fun and good to allow the player to create and develop own ones. So I want to know how you guys feel about this issue. Feel free to write in more detail after you voted.
GothicGothicness is offline

GothicGothicness

GothicGothicness's Avatar
SasqWatch

#1

Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 4,364

Default 

September 5th, 2009, 11:59
I have voted for "other"

The reason is, that I personally prefer story characters and don't need the option for self made ones. However I don't mind if the game has the option of self defined characters. So no option fitted exactly.

By the way, the reason for my preference for story charcters is immersion. I feel much more immersed if I identify with a being, which is already part of the world, has a history and so on.

Characters like the Witcher or nameless heros in PS:T and Gothic were more immersing for me than self made characters like in Baldurs Gate or NWN 2. They are also examples that story characters are not mutually excusive withinteresting character development.

I know that for other people the immersion feeling is greater, when they can define the hair colour and the name of their character, while things like that are irrelevant for me. However, I would like it, if they could have the possibility to do that.

May be there is a possibility to achieve both:

If you game will be party based you could implement it in such a way that every character in the group has the same options with respect to gameplay mechanics (so there is no pre-defined leader ofthe group as far as game mechanics are concerned).

You could then allow to mix the group from predefined characters with a story (and the story might require that have to have one or more of these in the party), while others are freely designable. The latter could for example have the typical non-story background like being a bhaalspawn orphan from a burned down village, but having no real personal story.

With such construction one player could chose a predefined story character as the lead of the group and play through the complete game this way, while another player could do the same with a completely self definned one. The have different roles in the story but both can be chosen as leader gameplaywise.



Addition: As an example, why for me immersion is stronger with predefined story characters instead ofself defined ones: If you consider being an actor in a theatre or a movie - which possibility is more interesting: To play a character, who is exactly like yourself or to play one, which is absolutely different from you normal self? For me it is clearly the second one.
bkrueger is offline

bkrueger

Nothing to see here.

#2

Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 797

Default 

September 5th, 2009, 12:26
I don't want to reveal too much, but I think you would be fairly satisfied with the system that is currently in the game. I will explain after more people replied to the poll, as to not affect the peoples opinion before it is done.
GothicGothicness is offline

GothicGothicness

GothicGothicness's Avatar
SasqWatch

#3

Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 4,364

Default 

September 5th, 2009, 23:13
I don't like having to make my own characters before I know what the game is about too much. I like developing my character in relation to the gameworld.
How would I know before the game starts if my character wants more strength or more charisma and so on … or to have the barter skill or …

I prefer the things like in Gothic, but more on the skills based thing than the story thing. I like the fact that the guy from let's say Fallout had some kind of past and so on…

I hope I'm making sense.

GG, the best of luck for your game and whenever it's in a state you're ready to show it to people, count me in

Also, please don't make it go vapourware like Grimoire and others.

EDIT: I voted for I want story characters …

I forgot, like I said, this is mostly a skills thing, so if I can play around first for a while and then the rest of the party I can choose or do things with then that's also ok. It's just the start that I don't like having to choose stuff, then play for hours to realize this particular build is bad or unenjoyable.
Pladio is offline

Pladio

Pladio's Avatar
Guardian of Nonsense
RPGWatch Donor

#4

Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: London, uk
Posts: 3,342
Send a message via MSN to Pladio

Default 

September 7th, 2009, 11:23
I really like the solution in Mass Effect, where the main character is only known as "Commander Shepard". That way, you still get to customize the character to a certain degree, and choose sex, but the developers are still able to build a decent story around the character.

It's something of a hybrid, but I like that solution.

Beyond that, I prefer recruiting interesting NPCs over making them. It adds to the story. A good solution would probably be:
- Let's say we have 5 character slots, 1 for the main character.
- 8-10 recruitable NPCs to recruit (4 available slots).
- The ability to custom build your own party instead of using the NPCs that you meet during the game. You can decide to create the main character + 2 NPCs, and recruit 2 NPCs later on (Baldur's Gate had such a system, but only if you started a multiplayer game).

Also, it's not a bad idea to increase the number of slots through game, for example based on Charisma (like in Arcanum). That way, even the later NPCs you find might be interesting (as you might just get an extra slot at level 30). I generally like the Arcanum solution a lot, where you can decide to either make a tougher main character, or a more charismatic one relying on henchmen/persuasive non-combat options.
Maylander is offline

Maylander

SasqWatch

#5

Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Bergen
Posts: 5,644
Send a message via MSN to Maylander

Default 

September 7th, 2009, 21:13
I want to create my character while other PCs in the party are story based.
wolfing is offline

wolfing

wolfing's Avatar
Wonders what SasqWatch is

#6

Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Tardis
Posts: 3,358

Default 

September 7th, 2009, 23:21
It really depends on the context of the game for me - I like creating my own sometimes, but so long as I have control at some point I'm fine with a Gothic type system.

— Mike
txa1265 is offline

txa1265

txa1265's Avatar
SasqWatch

#7

Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Corning, NY USA
Posts: 11,509

Default 

September 8th, 2009, 00:06
I much prefer having control over the development of all my characters, but not to the point where I'll ignore a good game that doesn't work that way.

Sorry. No pearls of wisdom in this oyster.
Dallas Cowboys: Still afraid to hope / / Detroit Red Wings: Another rollercoaster season?
dteowner is offline

dteowner

dteowner's Avatar
Shoegazer

#8

Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Indiana, USA
Posts: 11,357

Default 

September 8th, 2009, 15:59
Maybe an interesting alternative is to have storyline characters that you create when you meet them. Like, when you meet Ella the thief, the character screen comes up and you define her skills/abilities (with class locked as Thief in this case)
wolfing is offline

wolfing

wolfing's Avatar
Wonders what SasqWatch is

#9

Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Tardis
Posts: 3,358

Default 

September 8th, 2009, 16:41
Darn it wolfing, that's exactly how it works. Did you steal/peak at the games design documents??? I feel a bit worried now.. better check my PC for spyware

I might as well tell how it works now. There are some story characters vital to the storyline, the first time you meet with them you can place attributes etc ( it also fits in the storyline but I don't want to spoil why) but some characters are locked to their chosen baseclass, so for example if we have Wolfing the brave scout as a main story character, you could develop him in different paths according to the scout class ( Trapmaster, Hunter, Path finder ) etc.

You can also "recruit" characters in the game, when you do this you can do some re-rolling of stats, choose their class, add skills etc etc, their will be certain requirements and way to get different races, so you could not create anything you want directly from the start however as you progress in the game you could create and recruit more and more. This also satisfy the "all the characters are really part of the world requirement" that someone here wanted.

Also their is only one character which will be required in your team, except for that you can choose and mix between story and recruit characters.

I will give more info on the system later on.

Ideas and comments ???
GothicGothicness is offline

GothicGothicness

GothicGothicness's Avatar
SasqWatch

#10

Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 4,364

Default 

September 11th, 2009, 22:18
I was going to say that I would like I create my own character and pick up story pcs along the way like Baldur's gate, KOTOR, Mass Effect(even though the name never changes you have total control in what kind of character Shepard is) etc…. But I like the way you're doing it better. They're sorta a best of both worlds. Story mode characters mixed in with my own picks for their abilities.

Keep up the good work. This game is getting more interesting by the minute.

Despite all my rage.
I'm still just a rat in a cage.
skavenhorde is offline

skavenhorde

skavenhorde's Avatar
Little BRO Rat

#11

Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Taiwan
Posts: 5,408

Default 

September 12th, 2009, 05:17
It sounds like an interesting system. From what you've said so far it sounds like a game I'd try.

In my personal opinion, it is critical that at least one character be completely player created, with complete freedom of choice over their roleplaying background as well as their skills/stats/etc. Beyond that, I'm happy whether the other characters are player created or story created.
Arundor is offline

Arundor

Watcher

#12

Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 20

Default 

September 12th, 2009, 13:42
On paper it sounds fun to create the whole party from scratch but it becomes rather dull quite fast. Most often story character is the best way to go. That is if you wish player to feel something for his party members. Baldur's gate 2 would be a much lesser game without all the wonderfull party interaction. Besides its really difficult to build a decent story otherwise.

However despite the predefined backrounds I like to be in nearly full control how they level up. Class choise on the otherhand should be predefined. Mincs is a ranger, Jaheira is a druid, hk 17 is a battle droid, Cart is a soldier…I would only wish to change my party member's class if it was part of the game's storyline, like transferring khelgar into a monk he always wanted to be.
Dez is offline

Dez

Dez's Avatar
Watcher of The Keep

#13

Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 1,194

Default 

September 28th, 2009, 15:40
Although I just voted for "Yes, I only want my own characters" I like the design choice and would be more than happy to play that way .
PaladinPatrick is offline

PaladinPatrick

Traveler

#14

Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 3

Default 

October 5th, 2009, 05:36
In heavily combat oriented dungeon crawlers, I much prefer a custom party. In a heavily story-based game, static (or at least only mildly customizable) characters are needed.

So in short, I'd be happy regardless of the decision. I do like the design choice, and the way it is presented. Being able to alter the character to an extent may help cure some of the woes I notice with purely static pre-defined PC's in many games I've played.

It was the night before Hogswatch…

I became insane with long intervals of horrible sanity - Edgar Allan Poe
azraelck is offline

azraelck

azraelck's Avatar
Angel of Cookies!

#15

Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: In the Middle of Nowhere
Posts: 1,861
Send a message via AIM to azraelck Send a message via Skype™ to azraelck

Default 

November 10th, 2009, 16:58
I cannot think of a better way to say it right now or another game, but I liked the system in Final Fantasy Tactics (although I am not a big fan of the series). I like having some main story charecters but also having the ability to recruit (create) other charecters.

I liked the Wiz8 system as well, but I didn't feel that you got immersed into the story enough.
Viper2904 is offline

Viper2904

Traveler

#16

Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 7

Default 

September 7th, 2012, 21:34
Voted "other". While I can take or leave RPCs (Recruite-able Player Characters…what you seem to call "story characters") and MUST have the ability to create most of my party myself, I think the best way is to have RPCs (2 or 3) you can recruit if you so choose. The advantages could be that certain RPCs are in some way or other more powerful than what you can create but perhaps the advantage of creating all your PCs is flexibility and/or being able to create exactly what you think you need to survive and thrive.

For my money a game that allows you to create 8 PCs OR create 5, 6 or 7 PCs and recruit others would be best. That way everyone is happy. Don't want to create 8 PCs? Fine. Create 4 or 6 and recruit some more later. May be a bit tougher in the beginning but maybe easier once you find the RPCs you want.

"I am in a very peculiar business; I travel all over the world telling people what they should already know." - James Randi
SkeleTony is offline

SkeleTony

SkeleTony's Avatar
Skeptic

#17

Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Tacoma, WA
Posts: 36
RPGWatch Forums » Games » Indie RPG » Tactica: Maiden of Faith » Story Characters vs Player Made Characters
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

All times are GMT +2. The time now is 05:14.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright by RPGWatch