G2 with NotR included, G1 if add-ons are not allowed.
I think nobody will chose Gothic3. I hope there will be another Gothic, because it's a bit sad that the series would end with such a lesser game.
@ MasterLich: I don't see why do you judge Gothic 4 and the new Devs that early, I mean what you imply is an option but not the only option
I'm not really implying anything meaningful, it's just that the comment of Bart about the series ending in Gothic 3 was probably not correct.
Gothic 2 with or without is my fave Gothic and one of my top 5 games of all time regardless of genre or platform.
You're one of the people that played G2 before you played G1 aren't you?
Just curious.
3) the mod: Piratenleben
?! I've not heard of this, what is it?