Skyrim - Dawnguard Review @ Eurogamer

Dhruin

SasqWatch
Joined
August 30, 2006
Messages
11,842
Location
Sydney, Australia
The first full review of the Skyrim DLC Dawnguard that we've tracked is up at Eurogamer. The score is a modest 7/10, with the author finding the story too thin and new features such as the Vampire Lord form a bit clumsy. The intro:
Dawnguard, the first download add-on for Bethesda's world-conquering Skyrim, is a curious thing. Unlike the blockbuster ambitions of BioWare, Bethesda RPGs are more about place than plot. They're about roaming, poking around and seeing what happens, and the various quest lines are there to tug you in the direction of new places.
That's why Bethesda downloadable content usually introduces some new, separate area to explore, away from the main map. Dawnguard, in contrast, squeezes its handful of new locations into the tiny spaces not already occupied in Tamriel. That means that a lot of its impact relies on the story, and that's not the game's strongest suit.
More information.
 
Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Messages
11,842
Location
Sydney, Australia
Wow, that was pretty harsh. While the rating is 7/10, the text says 4/10. The guy is right when he says that Bethesda is best at expansive environments and probably weakest at telling a story. I'll wait and see if this guy is a hater, or if this is a consensus. I guess the good thing about the Xbox 360 exclusive is that pc buyers get at least a month to read reviews before deciding to buy. This may be a good thing for us and a bad thing for Bethesda. Time will tell....
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
8,821
Wow, that was pretty harsh. While the rating is 7/10, the text says 4/10. The guy is right when he says that Bethesda is best at expansive environments and probably weakest at telling a story. I'll wait and see if this guy is a hater, or if this is a consensus. I guess the good thing about the Xbox 360 exclusive is that pc buyers get at least a month to read reviews before deciding to buy. This may be a good thing for us and a bad thing for Bethesda. Time will tell….

Not sure that will matter I think most will buy it anyway. I know I will.
 
I'm not really surprised the really good add-on came late for morrowind and oblivion, but hey this one beats horse armor.
 
Joined
Aug 13, 2011
Messages
119
horse armor didn't cost $20.
 
Joined
Oct 26, 2006
Messages
1,386
Location
California
Hm. The review did not sound very encouaging - I would play as a human (non-were, non- bow-using) so it sounds like it would be rather bland experience for me? So far I have logged 160hrs on plain old Skyrim and paying $20 for what sounds like an extended quest set on the same landmass is not sounding that appealing. Is this billed as an 'expansion' or as something less? I suppose my expectations were pitched a little high,having plaued old 'expansions' like Bloodmoon and Shivering Isles…
 
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
2,139
Location
Cape Town, South Africa
Hm. The review did not sound very encouaging - I would play as a human (non-were, non- bow-using) so it sounds like it would be rather bland experience for me? So far I have logged 160hrs on plain old Skyrim and paying $20 for what sounds like an extended quest set on the same landmass is not sounding that appealing. Is this billed as an 'expansion' or as something less? I suppose my expectations were pitched a little high,having plaued old 'expansions' like Bloodmoon and Shivering Isles…

Maybe you want to wait until it comes out for PC so we can post some feedback?

It includes two new faction questlines and at least one long sidequest. I will probably go back and play two or three new playthroughs of the game, one siding with the Dawnguard and the other siding with the Volkihar. In my case, two new playthroughs means at least few hundred hours.
 
Joined
Jan 15, 2011
Messages
1,477
Location
Chocovania
I think that after a handful of different playthroughs of Skyrim I've now reached saturation point... this add-on comes a little too late for me and does not offer enough in terms of new exploration to make purchase worthwhile.

I think I will wait for all add-ons to be released and a compilation edition to be sold - then one or two playthroughs with a "complete" game.
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
143
I wouldn't hold my breath if I were you.

No? They released 5 expansions for FO3, and that game sold roughly 2.7 million copies. Skyrim sold more than 3.5 million copies, in 48h.. I'm pretty sure we'll see a lot of expansions for Skyrim.
 
Joined
Apr 18, 2011
Messages
3,263
Location
The land of rape and honey
No? They released 5 expansions for FO3, and that game sold roughly 2.7 million copies. Skyrim sold more than 3.5 million copies, in 48h.. I'm pretty sure we'll see a lot of expansions for Skyrim.

I'm all for it, of course, but I seem to recall Todd mentioned in an interview that the subsequent DLC will be smaller than Dawnguard.
 
Joined
Jan 15, 2011
Messages
1,477
Location
Chocovania
I think it's probably a good idea to make a distinction between actual expansions and DLC. I've not seen any DLC yet to rival genuine expansions such as Tribunal or Bloodmoon for length/breadth for instance.

The Eurogamer review doesn't make Dawnguard sound all that appetising, unfortunately, at least for me. I'll wait for more opinions on the Watch naturally, but otherwise I may delay my mage playthrough of Skyrim until the rest of the DLC comes out.
 
Joined
Jul 12, 2009
Messages
1,974
Location
Australia
That's odd since he said they were aiming for large expansions this time around, at least in interviews a few months ago.

Maybe they are testing out this $20 price point; hopefully, if it is successful they might develop more DLC of this scope.
 
Joined
Jan 15, 2011
Messages
1,477
Location
Chocovania
I'm all for it, of course, but I seem to recall Todd mentioned in an interview that the subsequent DLC will be smaller than Dawnguard.

What he said was that they would be doing fewer DLC than they did with Fallout 3 - and that each would be on the more substantial side (ie, no operation anchorage).

I disagree with the review here a bit - he seemed dismissive about one of the best and most substantive quests in the expansion because it requires reading a book. Like people don' click on books already hoping one will be a skill-book. I'm also suspicious they didn't actually finish one play-through of either side based on how they compared the two - in terms of quality of quests and interesting abilities you can get by the end of each main route, its unbalanced toward the Dawnguard if anything and certainly not the other way around. But you have to actually get to the end of the quest line to realize that, so I suspect they didn't.

It also adds a fairly substantial amount of explorable new areas (2-3 vallys, a realm of oblivion, and even a new location in Black Reach.) He seems disappointed they're not all conveniently in one new place - which I guess would have made it hard to see all of them and be first out of the gate with a review like this. There's at least a few interesting things to find in the Soul Carn if you actually explore it including side quests and a hidden boss-ish fight.

It's got flaws alright, and the score isn't entirely unreasonable depending on your playstyle. If you really enjoyed skyrim then it's probably more of an 8/10; if you got bored of skyrim and never finished it then well yeah this would be a waste of money.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 20, 2006
Messages
1,710
What he said was that they would be doing fewer DLC than they did with Fallout 3 - and that each would be on the more substantial side (ie, no operation anchorage)

Yes, I'm familiar with that part, but there was a video interview with Todd Howard where he said not all the DLC was going to be $20 or as big as Dawnguard.
 
Joined
Jan 15, 2011
Messages
1,477
Location
Chocovania
Dawnguard sounds really weak compared to Shivering Isles, Bloodmoon or Tribunal though :/ Wish they would make something like that for Skyrim.

This is what I was hoping for as well.

When they first announced Dawnguard, I was a little skeptical about what I was seeing, and this review seems to confirm a lot of my concerns. I'm sure there's some nice extra questlines and a few new locations to see, but I was hoping for something more expansive like Shivering Isles (which I sense we may not see with Skyrim, there seems to be more focus on DLC than full blown expansions these days).

I'll probably pick it up when it eventually gets a deep discount on Steam, but not for a full $20. I'll keep an eye out for other reviews as well, but so far I've seen little in the previews and whatnot that makes me want to break out my wallet.
 
Joined
Mar 7, 2012
Messages
190
Well I just picked up 1600 MS Points to buy this thing.

So, what are the things to look out for?

Vampire Quest?

Extra Werewolf Quest?
  • I wasn't too thrilled with the gourging depicted when a werewolf so I've opted not play it for the most part. I keep the blood to be immune to disease. Is there an alternative now, like playing a Silver Blade?

Crossbows?

What else is in this.

As a few people also pointed out, there are no massive extra continents and no level cap to be increased. Skyrim is pretty massive to begin with, doncha think?

--

On a side note, in last night's Futurama the voting districts for President of Earth consisted of Skyrim, Panem, Kenya, R'yleh, and of course, Iowa.
 
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Messages
5,212
Location
The Uncanny Valley
Back
Top Bottom