Demon Souls
I liked Demon Souls, purchased Dark Souls ps3, but haven't gotten around to playing it yet.
One of the things I like about Demon Souls, is it isn't about mindless hack and slash like Skyrim (not saying I haven't enjoyed Skyrim), or even click, kill, click, its more about fighting technique, making use of every point of stamina / magic because running out generally means death. Die, try again only with more attention to technique. It isn't a game one plays half asleep. Progressing into the game only makes fighting more interesting.
The online component makes things interesting, especially being invaded. From what I gathered from posts from other users, Dark Souls has glaring problems with invasion, since few restrictions were placed on the level an invader could be vs. the "victim". While in Demon Souls, invasions are more fair. Have to say I've only won one out of five however. Might be due to twinking or muling more than my technique. My character only has equipment = level.
The nice thing is, if one doesn't care to be invaded then its possible to suicide in the Nexus (dying in worlds causes soul tendency to shift, so its safe to die in The Nexus), and play in soul form.
If it sounds complicated, it is, but I've never played a game that made me so nervous to play, wondering if, this time, I could make it through and live, and also, wondering when the next surprise was…around the next corner, "Good Gods, look at all those lava lizards.."
The players are great, we see each other as ghosts, leave notes for each other, and in a way, adventure together, though silently. There is a type of co-op but matching up with a friend is difficult at best, however I have had co-op sessions that were a blast, even with somebody I didn't know, and could not communicate with.
Some like Demon Souls more than Dark Souls, eventually I'll get around to playing Dark Souls and come up with a comparison.
Horrible, messy review, and on Demon Souls more than Dark Souls, but I thought I'd post what I like about these games, they appear to be third person hackers, but they are really much more than that. We need more of these..Legend of Grimrock will probably bring me back to the olde keyboard.
I'm also playing Wizardry: Labyrinth of Lost Souls (PSN only), not a great game, but not totally horrible either. That is a messy review for another time.