Witcher IGN Review - 8,5 :)

@chamr we don't really disagree. All I'm saying is that a reviewer who reviews RPGs for an RPG audience has to take his audience into account. He fulfills both roles, both that of a journalist and that of a critic. If his audience is going to absolutely adore a hypothetical game, his review has to reflect that, both in content and score. Eg a historian on the other hand has no such bounds, and is free to more explicitly stress any negative aspects.