I prefer this one.

pibbur who may (or may not) change his mind

The wooden watchtower reminds me of the fire towers back home. Still a watchtower but the stone one seems more appropriate to the content here.

Anyone who still knows Buster Keaton?

http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/attac…1&d=1424805900

http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/attac…1&d=1424805935

I'll say it again. We need space for an ads banner, 468x60.

Like this?

http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/attac…1&d=1424814700

Yes here is an example based on our Halloween Banner.

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y26…_center_ad.jpg

Okay:

http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/attac…1&d=1424815863

Logo shouldn't encompass any ads… else it's a site FOR the ad and not a site WITH an ad…

I agree with drithius

If there are ads, who gives a shit if they're on top of the logo, really? The site in question is still hosting them, so…

I do, and Drithius apparently does too.

It looks odd in my opinion and makes the logo ugly too.

I would prefer the logo's base width to be shorter and then leave space for ads on the right, like the old GOG ad used to work.

Having a stretched out logo with an ad in the middle looks odd to me.

I like, actually!

Well, I guess I can't really see the difference between ads on the right side of the logo and ads on the empty side of the logo.

But it's hardly worth discussing.

I'm pretty impartial since it's not my site and I don't feel entitled to make any kind of decision regarding its logo.

Change LucasArts into Bethesda and you have my instavote! :evilgrin:

Btw, I'm old enough to know who Buster Keaton was.
Almost born in the same year as him. :D

It's not your site, but it doesn't mean your opinion does not matter at all.

In the end Myrthos has the final say, but I like to think he reads comments and adjusts his decisions based on them.

Yeah, but I'd rather he listens to those who really care :)

I prefer this one and I don't like ads on the logo as well :)

I like the first Watchtower of the Watch as well…

http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/attac…1&d=1424891577

http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/attac…1&d=1424892124

or this one :)

http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/attac…1&d=1424894176

is it true? ;)
http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/attac…1&d=1424894808

http://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/attac…1&d=1424895148

Hi guys, hope I'm not stepping on any toes but I thought I would throw my hat in the ring with a logo suggestion of my own. It's a first attempt and I'm sure it can be improved. Kept it one colour vector art so that it can be used in any colour scheme. This will make it easy to adapt to the different sub-sites and colour schemes. Also easy for printing on tshirts or mugs or anything else for that matter. Even if you don't go with my proposal I would recommend you go with a vector based artwork. Much easier to use in the long run.

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/…rpgwatch-1.jpg

Lemonhead, I think that's great. A professional-looking logo that can easily be used in the banner, and anywhere else.