RPGWatch Forums

RPGWatch Forums (https://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/index.php)
-   News Comments (https://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   Wasteland 3 - Review @ Gameffine (https://www.rpgwatch.com/forums/showthread.php?t=45893)

HiddenX September 10th, 2020 22:39

Wasteland 3 - Review @ Gameffine
 
Gameffine has reviewed Wasteland 3:

Quote:

Wasteland 3 Review :: Six Desert Rangers Walk into a Bar

I love inXile Entertainment, no questions asked. inXile founder Brian Fargo is a monumental figure in the RPG scene whose contributions to the genre cannot be understated. I've played all of their games starting with The Bard's Tale 16 years ago. Even though none of their RPGs - Wasteland 2, Torment: Tides of Numenera, or The Bard's Tale IV quite hit the sweet spot, their passion for the genre is clear. I was always hopeful that, given the sufficient budget, resources, and time, they could pull off a real gem. A successful crowdfunding campaign, the acquisition by Microsoft, and with Deep Silver acting as the publisher, Wasteland 3 looked like inXile's best shot to make it big. Being a long-time Wasteland fan, and one who enjoyed Wasteland 2 immensely despite the terrible second half, I was all up for it. 65 hours and 1.5 playthroughs later, here are my thoughts on Wasteland 3.

[…]

Real Talk

Wasteland 3 is, in essence, an improved version of its predecessor. The writing, quests, and combat have been improved and polished upon by a large margin but there are a few design choices that stick out like a sore thumb. Technical issues, broken co-op, and a bloated UI hold the game back from its true potential. The game doesn't break any new ground but that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Still, at a time when RPGs are defying tried and tired tropes to provide a fresh experience, you wish there was more inXile could have done with the increased budget and resources. So, If you're a die-hard fan or someone trying to get into CRPGs, Wasteland 3 is an easy buy with some caveats. Those on the fence can try the game out on Xbox Game Pass or wait for the developers to patch out the issues.

Score: 7.8/10

More information.

Couchpotato September 10th, 2020 22:43

@yemeth I agree with everything you wrote. Another good review.:thumbsup:

Wisdom September 11th, 2020 00:18

Quote:

65 hours and 1.5 playthroughs later, here are my thoughts on Wasteland 3.
Nice one Jay.

Ah…. and people wonder why independent reviewers are better than giant gaming sites that spend 30 minutes reviewing early access preview material and balancing that against how much advertising revenue the publishers provided.

tekulte September 11th, 2020 01:50

Well, I do agree with the review overall, but I guess I'm lucky. I don't have a top-of-the-line rig but with all graphics settings at the highest, I've never seen any kind of fps drops. It has, however, froze up twice while loading a saved game (from within the game). But 2 in 65 hours of play ain't bad, and at least the save wasn't corrupted.

yemeth September 11th, 2020 04:34

Glad you guys liked the review :)
I kept annoying Brian Fargo on Twitter regarding some of the QoL changes and hopefully they'll patch out the issues soon.

henriquejr September 11th, 2020 05:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by yemeth (Post 1061615004)
I kept annoying Brian Fargo on Twitter regarding some of the QoL changes and hopefully they'll patch out the issues soon.

Oh please, keep doing that :)

Kylex September 11th, 2020 07:06

Quote:

…bloated UI…
Searching for "bloated" within the review und comparing this to my experience I would describe the UI as too minimal, not "bloated". Strange wording for the UX within this review.

JFarrell71 September 11th, 2020 07:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kylex (Post 1061615014)
Searching for "bloated" within the review und comparing this to my experience I would describe the UI as too minimal, not "bloated". Strange wording for the UX within this review.

I have yet to see a game come out and not have its UI criticized. It's just one of those things people are never happy with.

yemeth September 11th, 2020 07:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kylex (Post 1061615014)
Searching for "bloated" within the review und comparing this to my experience I would describe the UI as too minimal, not "bloated". Strange wording for the UX within this review.

The UI is not just the HUD, it includes the inventory, the upgrade, journal, and stats screen as well. Imo they're designed with controllers in mind and just a hassle to navigate. Not to mention the 1 sec micro-lag every time you go to a new screen. I prefer a more compact UI that shows me all the info I need in less mouse clicks. In fact, I think WL2 had a much better inventory and stats screen.

bjon045 September 11th, 2020 09:30

Looks like a fair review. Like always I am going to wait until they patch out most of these kinks and hopefully add a bit of polish. And who knows, there might even be a small expansion on the cards given the success it has been so far.

SpoonFULL September 11th, 2020 13:49

Yemeth, I also liked your other balanced and fair reviews including the Mortal Shell one. Thanks for your hard work.

yemeth September 11th, 2020 14:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by SpoonFULL (Post 1061615042)
Yemeth, I also liked your other balanced and fair reviews including the Mortal Shell one. Thanks for your hard work.

:D Thank you for the kind words

yemeth September 11th, 2020 14:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by bjon045 (Post 1061615031)
Looks like a fair review. Like always I am going to wait until they patch out most of these kinks and hopefully add a bit of polish. And who knows, there might even be a small expansion on the cards given the success it has been so far.

I heard there are some content updates on the way but they are prioritizing the bugfixes

Nereida September 11th, 2020 16:00

Oh look, a review I can agree with, with a score I can agree with.

Good job. (Obviously because I agree with it!).

Pladio September 11th, 2020 16:12

Quote:

Someone give the music director an award
I’m in love with the sound design of Wasteland 3. Pretty much every dialogue is voice acted – and this even applies to the random chitchat between NPCs. While the quality of the voiceovers varies between characters, it’s always a pleasure to play a fully voice-acted RPG. Wasteland 3 also uses covers of several classic licensed songs during key sequences and this is something that adds an epic feeling to combat encounters. Repelling enemy attacks alongside a gigantic statue of Donald Reagan while “America the Beautiful” blasts in full volume in the background or chilling to the game’s rendition of “Everybody Have Fun Tonight” while sharing questionable meat with a group of cannibals adds a layer of the sublime to the game.
I loved the music in those scenes. It was really a nice touch !

Couchpotato September 11th, 2020 23:42

Have to agree the music fit the setting this time.:nod:

loading…

JDR13 September 12th, 2020 03:58

Ugh.. that first track is god-awful. Is that actually in the game?

The rest seem like pretty good BGM.

Couchpotato September 12th, 2020 04:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by JDR13 (Post 1061615096)
Ugh.. that first track is god-awful. Is that actually in the game?

Yes most of the songs will play at a boss fight, or on the overland map.

JFarrell71 September 12th, 2020 05:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by JDR13 (Post 1061615096)
Ugh.. that first track is god-awful. Is that actually in the game?

The rest seem like pretty good BGM.

Matter of taste, I guess. I love the first track. It plays early on when you fight a gang called the Dorseys.

Nereida September 12th, 2020 08:23

The music during key battles is pretty amazing I agree, very immersive in a way, and well fitting in most cases. Funny that to me too that first song together with "America the Beautiful" were by far the worst of them all. Felt so immersion breaking and generally dull and boring compared to most others. I think Blood of the Lamb is my favourite.

One thing I'll be thankful for to Wasteland 3, besides the fact that was a good game that was held back by how unpolished and buggy it was, is that it allowed me to explore MS Store to try out some pearls like The Dark Crystal Age of Resistance, Mistover, Dragon Quest XI or Disgaea 4 Complete, which are all pretty amazing games that had gone under my radar probably out of being busy with something else when they released. I've bookmarked them all and playing them one by one now while I await for other stuff to release, and it's being a treat.

This may have been one of the best £1 I ever spent, and likely will translate into extending the sub for at least one more month.

JFarrell71 September 12th, 2020 08:41

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nereida (Post 1061615104)
Funny that to me too that first song together with "America the Beautiful" were by far the worst of them all. Felt so immersion breaking and generally dull and boring compared to most others. I think Blood of the Lamb is my favourite.

Well, that's a pretty confusing opinion, given that the first song is Blood of the Lamb.

Edit: I'm dumb.

Nereida September 12th, 2020 09:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by JFarrell71 (Post 1061615105)
Well, that's a pretty confusing opinion, given that the first song is Blood of the Lamb.

Couchpotato linked the "Wasteland 3 Full Soundtrack Video" which clearly reads in the track list:

00:00 (ie, first track) - Battle Hymn of the Republic
…..
38:55 (ie, second to last track) - Blood of the Lamb

I don't see what's confusing, but my guess is you're ordering tracks in some way that's not the one provided in the ongoing conversation, thus confusing yourself.

JFarrell71 September 12th, 2020 09:56

I didn't read any track list, just pressed play, and yes, I mistook the song I was hearing for Blood of the Lamb. I only listened to a few seconds and the singer sounded similar to me.

Nereida September 12th, 2020 12:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by JFarrell71 (Post 1061615107)
I didn't read any track list, just pressed play, and yes, I mistook the song I was hearing for Blood of the Lamb. I only listened to a few seconds and the singer sounded similar to me.

Fair enough. the first few chords an even the tone of the song for the first 20 or so seconds do sound similar. :)


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 06:06.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
vBulletin Security provided by DragonByte Security (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2022 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2022 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright by RPGWatch