I've tried to match the keys we have to the winners and the keys they want. Unfortunately it looks like the 'The Tenth Line' keys are incorrect and there aren't 5 Star Traders games, there is just one.
It was not possible to match all keys to a winner, given the restrictions that were made for what key people wanted to win. As a results there are a couple of keys left, which will be used in the next key giveaway.
abharsair|Brigand: Oaxaca
akarthis|Tempest
Alrik Fassbauer|Hob
Arkadia7|The Walking Dead: Season 1
axellslade|HeroCraft
azsinistar|Just One Line
beldurax|Brigador: Up-Armored Edition
bjon045|Icewind Dale Complete (classic)
Black Rune|The Flame in the Flood
Cantello|Chroma Squad
Capt. Huggy Face|Rebel Galaxy
Carnifex|Star Traders: Frontiers
codexcat|Highlands: Deep Waters
Dajjer|All Walls must Fall (4 times)
Dark Savant|Risen 3: Titan Lords - Complete Edition
Darkbridger|Gods will be watching
Darkheart|Fall of Light
darklord|No Turning Back: The Pixel Art Action-Adventure Roguelike
daveyd|Stellar Tactics
deiland|Castle Torgeath: Descent into Darkness
deliciousdoc|Undertale
Dez|Styx: Master of Shadows
Elwro|Ocklos
fabrulana|Divinity Original Sin 2 Collector Edition
Farflame|Endless Legend – Classic Edition
fatknacker50|Galactic Civilizations Ultimate Edition
Ferris_bg|NWN Diamond
Gabriel|Sam & Max: Devil's Playhouse
gabrielarantest|Her Story
GabrielMP_19|CONSORTIUM
goblin|Sam & Max Season 2
Goraidh|Walking Heavy
gulla|Divinity II: The Developer's Cut
Gunderson105|Secret Files: Tunguska
Gwendo|Song of the Myrne: What Lies Beneath
Heckle|Bebob and Tempo
HellRazor|The Shrouded Isle
henriquejr|Armello
hollywood_vamp|The Walking Dead: Season 1
ilm|Caveblazers
JaakkoPeltonen|HeroCraft
JDR13|Solstice Chronicles
KaosWarMonk|Pillars of Eternity
lostforever|Ashes of the Singularity: Escalation
Luethar|The Walking Dead: Season 1
Lynchden|The Bard‘s Tale
Majnun|Epistory - Typing Chronicles
mbpopolano24|The Flame in the Flood
Mosaic|Lost Horizon
muhabor|Stellar Tactics
MysterD|Champions of Odin
Nephologist|Shadowrun: Dragonfall – Director‘s Cut
Nukester|Hand of Fate
Odrid|Planetary Annihilation: Titans
Ozymandias|Master of Orion
Padda|Shoppe Keep
Phoonzang|Shadowrun Returns
porcozaur|RYSE: Son of Rome
purpleblob|Baldur's Gate 2 Complete (classic)
rad_ical|Bebob and Tempo
Ragnaris|Kingdom: New Lands
Reiga|Rencounter
RikusTyr|Tauronos
rune_74|VoidExpanse
Silver|Zeno Clash 2
SirJames|Any Soldak game: Zombasite
skally_wag|DiRT Rally
Steinawarjar|Bioshock
Stingray|Risen 3 + Titan Lords - Adventure Garb + Fog Island + Uprising of the Little Guys
Strafe|Any Soldak game: ??
TheSnarkyShaman|The Walking Dead: Season 2
They Live|Stellar Tactics
TomRon|Any Soldak game: ??
vidder|Any Soldak game: Zombasite
Vitirr|Crystal Dynamics
Wenzil|Any Soldak game: Zombasite
wiretripped|Rollers of the Realm
Wisdom|Stellar Tactics
Xarg|STALKER: Clear Sky
you|Stellar Tactics
zahratustra|The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing Final Cut
With the exception of the Soldak games, all winners will receive their key today via PM (I do not have the keys for the Soldak games yet).