Originally Posted by DarkELVES
Only 4 out of 5 stars? You nuts?

Went back and forth in my head a lot with the rating. It's a tough one. It's sort of a strong 4, and an EE is very likely to be a full score. However, I've only handed out one full score, ever, and that was TW3 which blew me away from start to finish.

The "cons" mentioned are just enough to prevent it from getting a full score, but barely. As I pointed out in the article: It really is a fantastic game.

Edit: Also, Corwin gave the previous one a full score, but it's worth keeping in mind that Corwin is a much nicer person than I am.