Ideally, both games will be so good it comes down to personal taste which one is better. However, that is fairly unlikely - one of them will probably be significantly better than the other.
Ideally, both games will be so good it comes down to personal taste which one is better. However, that is fairly unlikely - one of them will probably be significantly better than the other.
I'm having trouble seeing why you feel the controversy is invalid. Sure, it would be nice to get two great games, no doubt about it, and that may happen. But one of them WILL inevitably be better than the other. So I don't see any reason why speculating which one that will be falls into the "nonsense" category. I don't even know what exactly a "psuedo-controversy" is, but I bet the internet snobbery elite invented the term for the sole purpose of raining negativity down on otherwise interesting threads.
Of course, if you take *any* pair of games, one of them may be better than the other one.
And therefore you can start a thread in order to speculate, which of the two might be better.
But what is the use of that?
to compare art styles,