I really respect Obsidian, and I still watch SP (only because of DVR technology). The show is occasionally still funny, but not enough for me to drop $60 for a game. It's about 5-7 years too late, IMO. Maybe if it has decent reviews I'll pick it up on a Steam sale (30%+) after awhile, but that's about as far as I'd go.
Good news for Obsidian is that it seems there is enough interest still out there for it not to tank, unless of course these game magazines are being paid to manufacture "most anticipated game of 2014" votes. But they'd never do that…