RPGWatch - Game of the Year 2015

Originally Posted by rebi01
"Sorry, but this contents has finished and is closed now."

You need to be a member to vote.

2015
1. PoE
2. Underrail (would be one if not for the shitty design of Deep Caverns)
3. Serpent in the Staglands.

2016
1. TToN
2. BG1: SoD
3. Deus Ex MD

I didn't vote for 2015, only played 2 games and didn't enjoy both very much (PoE and SCL).

For 2016 though:
1. Deus EX: MD
2. D:OS 2
3. T: ToN

2015 for me:

Legend of Eisenwald

Underrail

Age of Decadence


Looking forward to:

Kingdom Come, Deliverance

2015
1. Witcher 3 (of course)
2. Pillars of Eternity
3. Fallout 4 (not much of an RPG, actually, but these are the only three I played, so FO4 gets third by default)

2016
1. Torment: Numenara
2. Mass Effect: Andromeda
2. Deus Ex: Mankind Divided

Too many colons next year, apparently…

Originally Posted by Sacred_Path
(pretty lame year, actually)

For who? I thought 2015 was at least on par with 2014 which was excellent for RPGs. When you put them together, they were two of the best consecutive years I've seen in a very long time.

2015
The Quest
The Fall of the Dungeon Guardians
Templar Battleforce

2016
Battle Brothers
Mount and Blade II
Kingdom Come: Deliverance

As usual, so many titles that I haven't played leaves me feeling a little narrow and limited in my gaming experiences. Nonetheless, it was a reasonably good year for RPGs and I look forward to many more adventures in 2016.

2015:
Pillars of Eternity
Age of Decadence
Avernum 2: Crystal Souls

2016:
Dark Souls III
Torment: Tides of Numenera
Avadon III: Warborn

Why I can't vote?

2015
1. Underrail
2. Invisible Inc
3. Avernum 2

2016
1. Halcyon 6: Starbase Commander (borderline RPG at best though)
2. Torment
3. Shround of the Avatar

EDIT: OK, disregard my post, I found what I was looking for. I was looking for it to be called a bit differently.

Black Closet and SOMA are RPGs?

Originally Posted by rebi01
"Sorry, but this contents has finished and is closed now."

Originally Posted by Myrthos
You need to be a member to vote.

I'm having the same problem.

Am I… not member enough? Is there a platinum membership I need to obtain or something?

Well lets see as I played a lot of RPGs this year.

2015

1. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
2. Pillars of Eternity
3. Fallout 4

2016

1. Torment: Tides of Numenera
2. Kingdom Come: Deliverance
3. Deus Ex Mankind Divided

Oh well I suppose I could be a hipster, and only pick indie RPGs also.

2015

1. Underrail
2. Age of Decandence
3. Serpent in the Staglands

2016

1. Avadon III: Warborn
2. Battle Brothers
3. Mount and Blade II

Tough call I say as to many good games are being released.

2015:

1. The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky Second Chapter
2. The Witcher 3
3. None - at least none of similar quality

2016:

None. I don't happen to wait for any games at all. All of them could turn out to be a disappointment, so what's the point in hyping myself up. No expectations = less chance to feel let down, more chance to be pleasantly surprised.

Originally Posted by DirtStar
I'm having the same problem.

Am I… not member enough? Is there a platinum membership I need to obtain or something?

Maybe you need more posts, like a few dozens. Usually that it the requirement at sites, as protection against people registering multiple new accounts to cheat in the polls.

Originally Posted by Archangel
2015
1. PoE
2. Underrail (would be one if not for the shitty design of Deep Caverns)
3. Serpent in the Staglands.

2016
1. TToN
2. BG1: SoD
3. Deus Ex MD

Underrail is getting a lot of votes. I placed it in my top 3. The Deep Caverns has also screwed me as I went down there without the bullets and repair kits I needed. My last save was a ways back when I figured this out and used my quick save. GRRRRRR

Originally Posted by Hastar
Underrail is getting a lot of votes. I placed it in my top 3. The Deep Caverns has also screwed me as I went down there without the bullets and repair kits I needed. My last save was a ways back when I figured this out and used my quick save. GRRRRRR

DC has plenty of supplies (at least for gun people) and for sure has enough repair kits. The design of quests and areas is what ruined it for me. But the first 2/3 of the game is awesome enough that it still deserves to be in top 3. I hope devs go over that last 1/3 and improve it. They added that last and didn't let people in Early Access go through it first and give their feedback.

Originally Posted by Pessimeister

2016:
Dark Souls III

Avadon III: Warborn

finally a post for dark souls

oh and avadon 3? thats a nice surprise, first time i hear about it

1. witcher 3
2. underrail
3. pillars

for next year

1. dark souls 3
2. deus ex 4
3. torment 2

Originally Posted by Elel
2015:
Maybe you need more posts, like a few dozens. Usually that it the requirement at sites, as protection against people registering multiple new accounts to cheat in the polls.

Ah, thanks for the help. I am a thorough lurker so I guess no voting. And +1 for the LoH SC vote. Boom.

Hard to vote for 2015 games as I haven't played enough of them and of the ones I've played I have only played 6 or 7 hours for most. Most of 2015 was catching up time on other games and completing them ie. XCOM with new expansion, D:OS EE, Shadowrun Dragonfall, Dark Messiah of Might and Magic, Tales of Maj'Eyal (a great roguelike rpg)

Still of the ones I've played which were released 2015 the ones that left the best impression were:

Games of 2015
1: Underrail
2: Shadowrun Hong Kong (at bit wordy and combat a bit easy but its Shadowrun)
3: Chaos Reborn (more tactical, strategy but has enough rpg elements to satisfy me)

*If I could have included expanded editions I would of put D:OS EE at number 1 as I played and finished it this year. Incidentally why is HOMM 3 HD in the list given its just a graphical update?

Games of 2016
1: XCOM 2 (I know - is it an rpg? But for me it most certainly is)
2: Divinity Original Sin 2
3: Torment: Tides of Numenera
----------------------------------------
4: Baldurs Gate: Siege of Dragonspear

Originally Posted by Myrthos
The GOTY2015, has finally arrived.

You mean THE REAL, ONE AND ONLY GOTY 2015 has finallty arrived !!!

The other ones (from other websites) were just warm-ups, at best