Elex I don't know….

Originally Posted by Alistair
You'll probably have to restart

Well. If you have to restart after dozens of hours play, it could be considered serious.

__

Originally Posted by RPGFool
Well. If you have to restart after dozens of hours play, it could be considered serious.

__

'Sho nuff. Just wondering where he got the idea from that one would have to restart after this patch. Did PB say that somewhere?

I'm fine now. I have armor and a weapon upgrade. I didn't realize there were map markers. The world is huge and some quests just aren't doable without location info.

Originally Posted by ToddMcF2002
I'm fine now. I have armor and a weapon upgrade. I didn't realize there were map markers. The world is huge and some quests just aren't doable without location info.

It's not like the game goes out of its way to communicate useful stuff like that.

It really is terrible in terms of UI and the new player experience.

Terrible is a bit harsh. It could have been better. I would say average at best.

Originally Posted by Hastar
Terrible is a bit harsh. It could have been better. I would say average at best.

The UI? Well, not only is it butt-ugly and clunky - but VITAL information is downright misleading, even after a few patches - and then there's all the information that's not even communicated to the player.

It's pathetic and inexcusable as far as I'm concerned.

Game still seems great, though.

What's the issue with quest markers? There's a big option called Track Quest or Show on Map or something on the quest log. It couldn't be much clearer :/

Originally Posted by Alistair
What's the issue with quest markers? There's a big option called Track Quest or Show on Map or something on the quest log. It couldn't be much clearer :/

Yet a lot of people miss that. I've seen several Reddit posts where people have been very surprised that was possible in a PB game.

However, that's not my problem with the UI.

It's primarily the misinformation related to the absolutely vital details of skills - where skills do NOT do what the text says they do. As well as stuff like the personality skills - that seem deliberately opaque in terms of function.

In a game that totally revolves around character progression and smart choices - it would seem to be a very important thing to communicate clearly to the player.

I mean, I could fix everything in 20 minutes if PB told me what skills actually did - and I could write crystal clear descriptions for their tooltips.

The fact that they obviously don't care about details like this, tells me more than enough about their approach to UI and new players.

I find it annoying that I have to spend a significant amount of time on Reddit or Google when I need to make a skill choice.

I'm the kind of guy who prefers to play games "as they were intended" - and I prefer to make informed choices based on in-game systems and information. I don't build characters based on guides or information I need to hunt down because skills don't do what you would expect them to do.

I can't build my character in my preferred way in Elex - because the system doesn't make intuitive sense. It's a mess, really.

Dart, are you playing it in English or a different language? I thought the descriptions were horrid in English, but I'm not sure which languages you read/write/speak.

Abominable. That's how I'd describe Elex UI. And I mean everything. Options, menus, descriptions… Everything.
It's just another consolecentered UI.

The only good thing is quickbar, but it can't really save the day on it's own.

I wish there was a group of modders out there dedicated to redo all these pathetic UI designs.

Originally Posted by crpgnut
Dart, are you playing it in English or a different language? I thought the descriptions were horrid in English, but I'm not sure which languages you read/write/speak.

I play in English

I speak a little German - but definitely not enough for something like skill tooltips. That's just about as complicated as you can get in any language - unless we're talking math descriptions

I realise I can peruse Reddit for a few hours to get a good idea of what the skills do, but I'll forget half of them as I'm playing. Meaning, I have to take a chance every now and then - as I refuse to take a break for every choice.

But I already invested a few points in bad skills first time I played. Not a big deal, I suppose - but it's very annoying when you're a little obsessed with making smart choices

I say this as someone who usually has a very intuitive sense of what complicated RPG mechanics do - and I'm not often wrong.

However, Elex actually lies to the player about certain skills - like the one that's supposed to continuously add HP to your guy. Apparently, it does not - according to Reddit.

Several other skills have similar issues.

My issue with that is that it's SO easy to fix - but they just don't bother.

Originally Posted by NewDArt
However, Elex actually lies to the player about certain skills - like the one that's supposed to continuously add HP to your guy. Apparently, it does not - according to Reddit.

It does not definetly. It's one time boost. I'm confirming it. Each time you pick it, it adds some small amount of HP that one time and never again.

I've seen in some "things to prioritize" article, perhaps that was even a guide, I remember it was linked in one of Elex threads… The problem was an article saying you should pick this skill as early as possible because "it adds hp on your every level up", something like that.
It doesn't.

Yes, I was very close to picking that skill as one of my first.

Meh. The UI could be improved (it still occasionally confuses me with the various icons), but I'm 160 hours in and haven't looked up any skill descriptions.

My advice is the same for every RPG - Use your RPG Senses skill IRL and don't sweat the small stuff. You can still easily build a capable character in ELEX with intelligent choices.

Ahh, so if you're intelligent enough - the misinformation goes away, and I'll be able to guess what something does, counter to the description.

Got it!

Well the translations are cheap and are actually rewrites instead.

Originally Posted by NewDArt
Ahh, so if you're intelligent enough - the misinformation goes away, and I'll be able to guess what something does, counter to the description.

Got it!

Nah, it just really isn't that serious.

I'm playing on Ultra difficulty and still wearing the starting armor in the game 70 hours in in Chapter 2. Haven't put a single point into Constitution or Strength. The game, thus far, does not require strict power spec'ing in any way to succeed. Few RPGs ever do in my experience.

So I don't sweat it.

Curious though, which descriptions are actually misinformation? The one I did question was Attack Strength, as it is vague (increases strength of "strikes" or something.) Yet it has a fist icon, so I assume it means melee. Could be wrong.

But I agree they could be improved. But certainly nothing to worry about to peruse Reddit for a few hours. Just wing it, bro. You've played RPGs before.

I enjoy making smart choices. It has nothing to do with it being necessary.

Making smart choices in Elex means you will breach the somewhat absurd curve sooner rather than later. So, that's a bonus.

Since the tooltips are so poor, it's kinda hard to say which ones are misleading - because I'm not sure what they actually do. But the HP skill I mentioned is a great example of misinformation.

The fact that they've chosen to ignore stats altogether as anything but prequisites for items is another highly unusual choice that they really should have communicated to the player. I've seen posts from several hardcore PB fans who have had to start over because they invested too many points in a stat, like strength - because they expected it to help with the melee damage.

A lot of people seem to have been very surprised by that - and so was I.

No, they didn't start over because the game was too hard - but because they enjoy making smart choices, just like me.

It's ok with me that you're blind to flaws in games you enjoy - but why do you have such a hard time accepting that I think the UI is bad?

I mean, it's not like I'm out to hurt you or the game. I'm just recognising there's an issue - which is something a LOT of Elex fans agree with.

Also, I'm not sure what my experience with RPGs has to do with this. It's not really relevant. Most of the Watch have played far more RPGs than you have - but that doesn't really change anything about the UI.

Finally, it has nothing to do with the game being hard. You sound like you're trying to give out advice about how to handle the game - but you're missing the point.

It's about frustration - not challenge.

Once again, I don't find anything challenging about going from quest to quest for hours to gain XP. To me, that's anything BUT challenging. In fact, it reminds me of auto-piloting through W3 - and that's not a good thing when you enjoy activities that require a mental investment.

I enjoy a challenge. I just don't enjoy waiting 10-15 hours before I can find a meaningful one.

In fact, if you accept that Elex is a waiting game for a long time - then it's possibly the easiest of the PB games so far - because you won't bother grinding XP until you're powerful. That means almost no combat and almost exclusively questing for hours and hours. Questing being about clicking buttons in dialogues (apart from all the "fun" running away). Most PB games don't allow major progress without fighting a little. At least, I don't remember that being an option.

To each his own, though.

It seems to be generally agreed that 'Attack Strength' increases your chance to stagger or knock down an enemy with a strong attack. It did seem to work that way for me.

But yeah, the skill descriptions, at least in the English version, could have been a lot better.