Foundation's Edge (Foundation #4) by Isaac Asimov
Thoroughly enjoyed this one and even more so than the original trilogy. A real page-turner, intricately plotted with various layers, and even though some themes seemed familiar and I could guess at some things, it was a very fun read. I liked how the story was continued, even though this is a standalone (with a mild cliffhanger). 5/5
Foundation and Earth (Foundation #5) by Isaac Asimov
I felt relatively disappointed. Foundation's Edge had multiple POVs, new behind-the-scenes mysteries to pop up in every chapter, converging stories and interesting musings, all against the backdrop of the Seldon Plan.
This book lacked almost all of those. There's only one POV and instead of a grand mystery we get a smallish feeling adventure journey with mostly bickering protagonists. I liked the ending though and I'm looking forward to continue reading the series after a break: next up will be Robots and Empire and The End of Eternity, followed at some point by the two Foundation prequels. 2/5
Ha, I just finished the Foundation series myself, only just having discovered Asimov. Though I also thought Foundation's Edge was the better of the two, I wasn't as disappointed by Foundation & Earth as you were. I was quite absorbed by the search for Earth, and what they'd find there.
Did you read them in chronological order, or in published order? I read the two prequels after, and though the first one was a little slow going, I really liked the second (Forward the Foundation). In all, I found his later Foundation novels better than the originals.
I've just finished Caves of Steel and started the Naked Sun. While "mystery" stories aren't really my thing, I am enjoying reading more of the same universe.
I've got the Culture series on my wishlist at the moment. How would you say it compares to Foundation?
Last edited: