Gothic 3 List of Paladins

This is my take/idea on the chalices and at the moment it remains open until proved otherwise.

When putting the twelve chalices on the pedastals and they are then consecrated/blessed or whatever, as you probably know the one on the left nearest to and facing the Innos statue doesn't have a caption as the others have - it's an 'odd-man-out' chalice, it doesn't say "blessed" chalice and therefore the last paladin you offer it to will *not* be able to recieve a "blessed chalice"

Also we know having 11 chalices will not enable the sequence but nothing suggests that *if* having 13, only then will the correct 12 will then be blessed - and one over obviously (maybe even cursed - and why not if it cannot be blessed!)......just a tiny idea and not to be fully dismissed just yet.
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
1,105
Location
North-West England
HiddenX
Thanks thats good to know. :)

curious, I am not trying to be rude but the burden of proof is in your head.
The moderator told you where you could look to see the proof, it's you have decided not to look and continue.

Yet you want/wanted us to believe you, which we are certianlly willing to do, without any proof what so ever, just a feeling (?).
Yes you are correct that he doesn't wear Paladin armor and but that means what exactly are you suggesting someone wearing Nordmar armor can't Become a Paladin if Innos chooses him to replace Cruez (or whatever the Paladin we killed name)?

If your only resolution is PB posting a comment to verifiy this then, you will be waiting a long time, as they would never get the game fixed if they took the time to come on a board everytime a quest was broken, they are a small Developer and thats what fans are for. ;)

Edit
Your also wrong about them being Robar's Paladins, their are Innos's. :)
 
Last edited:
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
2,772
your not being rude Acleacius, i enjoy these discussions. replace a paladin? innos has far more than 12 paladins, the ones you give them to are simply there for quest purposes. and only 3 or 4 of them actually have quests to restore there powers. the rest are simply there to say 'thanks for my powers back' and give you xp and other meaningless rewards. not having another paladin to give it to is so not the point as there are others in vengard who could still accept one. and it is for this amongst a laundry list of other reasons why there doesn't need to be a 12th paladin.

things i am not 100% sure of or remember but need to be addressed
1)is there still a quest left in active quests after the other 11 chalices are handed?
if not then believe there should be something else makes even less sense.
2)does frithof ever say anything about being a paladin? even if he was missing dialogue it would seem intentionally left out if an original story involving powers lost, and the dialogue when you return it. a bug would usually be confined to one of those being ommitted not everything altogether.
3)as i said before why would frithof be 'rockin' his balls' in the fire clan? guarding a statue of innos is not to noble of a duty for a paladin when countless temples of innos have fallen and all resistance is nearing an end. all the other paladins had reasons for where they were and nearly all were in myrtana. cruz was in mora sul because he had a chalice. and olivier was in myrtana but escorted milten(or the other way around) to the fire monastery to solve the mysteries of the chalice.
4)more to come...




they may serve innos but they are under command of rhobar so they are 'his' paladins. just as the paladins on khorinis were lord hagens via the chain of command but still rhobar's and innos's.

i'm not the one waiting and am perfectly happy with how pirahna bytes has made it. i simply am trying to help myself and others understand why. i was heartened to see at least one person on the world of gothic forums who shared this opinion, but even if that were not the case if someone sees things as in harmony and working order they need nothing but if someone finds problems somewhere they can complain all they want 'til their blood sugar gets so low they collapse but satisfication will come to them only when they solve the problem. so it really is 'you' who are the ones who are waiting for the developers to fix what 'you' think is the problem. i'll be delighted if they add any content to the game, i just don't want to see more people infuriated with the wonderful game if and when there is still no '12th paladin' after the final patch:)
 
Joined
Oct 26, 2006
Messages
1,386
Location
California
Back
Top Bottom