Kingmaker - Review and Interview

Silver

Silver

Spaceman
Staff Member
Supporter
Joined
February 13, 2014
Messages
9,314
Location
New Zealand
RockPaperShotgun reviewed Pathfinder: Kingmaker while GamesIndustry interviewed the team.

RockPaperShotgun

In a tabletop campaign, DMs use their storytelling skills as much as their rulebooks. They are able to assess in real time whether throwing another casual encounter, or killing that limping party member, would be a fun challenge or just an act of cruelty. But the spirit that governs Pathfinder: Kingmaker is incapable of showing such mercy.

Unless we count the options menu as part of the DM’s duties, in which case they are a generous being. They let me tweak various rules, such as deciding how strong the enemies will be (anything over “normal” is an exercise in masochism), choosing how often the game will auto-pause, and even allowing me to disable death. Even the more technical parts of the game, like levelling up the characters, can be fully automated.

[...]
Click to expand...
GamesIndustry.biz

"Pathfinder, like a number of tabletop role-playing games, is a turn-based system, and there are times where adapting turn-based mechanics to real-time mechanics can be a challenge," said Avellone. "It's something designers have wrestled with all the way back to Baldur's Gate 1, in which BioWare had to do a real-time system that simulated the turn-based rules.

"The other challenge is that Pathfinder is a rule-rich system, and there are a lot of classes, spells, and abilities to choose from. We implemented many of them for the game, but we weren't able to include every race, class, and skill - even though I think we did an impressive number, there's simply too many to do them all for this first Pathfinder game anyway. If we do more, we'd be able to expand on the ones we made for this game. It was one of the reasons we had the scaling Kickstarter goals we did - we wanted to make sure we were budgeting realistically for what we could accomplish, and it made the reasons transparent to the backers as well.

[...]
Click to expand...
Thanks Farflame!

More information.
 
Joined
Feb 13, 2014
Messages
9,314
Location
New Zealand
Why make a turn based game into a real time one?
 
Joined
Jul 30, 2007
Messages
320
But the spirit that governs Pathfinder: Kingmaker is incapable of showing such mercy.
Click to expand...

Yes, my Intel CPU is notably lacking in the quality of mercy. I'm hoping a Ryzen will be better.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 8, 2014
Messages
12,085
Silver said:
Probably because of all the stories they wished to tell. A mass battle between goblins as occured in my playthrough would take too long in turn based.
Click to expand...

I've been playing Kingmaker for over 50 hours and I'm still in chapter 3. Mind you, I haven't had chance to explore all the maps so far either. I actually thinks devs are right and the game is 120 hours on a completionist run. Can you imagine if this is TB? I'd say it will be over 200 hours then with 150 hours of combat.
 
purpleblob said:
I've been playing Kingmaker for over 50 hours and I'm still in chapter 3. Mind you, I haven't had chance to explore all the maps so far either. I actually thinks devs are right and the game is 120 hours on a completionist run. Can you imagine if this is TB? I'd say it will be over 200 hours then with 150 hours of combat.
Click to expand...

Agreed. If they were trying to show an invasion in turn based they would show a max 6 units to keep it manageable. Its the advantage of the video game form. Being able to make multiple different decisions in RTWP is unique to computing and allows for many interesting decisions to be made that couldn't in tabletop with its turn based restrictions.

With a quality RTWP implementation and many difficulty options for people to choose its a no brainer.

* I like turn based and RTWP but only when done well obviously.
 
Joined
Feb 13, 2014
Messages
9,314
Location
New Zealand
Personally for me, being turn based would only improve the game. With that said, I'm still having a blast playing it, my preference is turn based but this game is worth playing regardless.
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2011
Messages
18,989
Location
Holly Hill, FL.
Long live the RPGWatch Turn-Based Guild. :ahoy:

If you're RPG isn't Turn-Based it doesn't deserve to be called one.

This is sarcasm by the way as I enjoy both but prefer RTwP.
 
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
36,351
Location
Spudlandia
Two more average reviews.

Pathfinder: Kingmaker Review - GameSpot Score: 6/10
All-told, Kingmaker isn't a stellar outing, hampered by a litany of small issues, balancing, and the gargantuan knowledge base you'll need to play most effectively. But, for those with the patience, the rewards are well worth the investment.
Click to expand...
Pathfinder: Kingmaker Review - Twinfinite Score: 3/5
The case in favor of Pathfinder: Kingmaker comes with an overwhelming series of excuses. Epic quest lines exist, but a boring second act hampers them. The kingdom management shows unique advancement, but it houses nasty unresolvable events that result in a game over. Companions develop along fantastic storylines of their own but share mundane paths with mediating low-stakes conflict. With frequent technical issues on top of these, Pathfinder: Kingmaker remains hard to recommend at the moment.
Click to expand...
 
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
36,351
Location
Spudlandia
Couchpotato said:
Two more average reviews.

Pathfinder: Kingmaker Review - GameSpot Score: 6/10Pathfinder: Kingmaker Review - Twinfinite Score: 3/5
Click to expand...

Even though I agree with both of the synopsis listed above, I still enjoy the game quite a bit. It is buggy, the 2nd chapter is amazingly dull. But...this is the first game and I think Owlcat has enough good stuff that I would back a 2nd game. I hated PoEt (as opposed to PoEx), and so wouldn't and didn't back the 2nd game. However, I've heard it was really good and may give it a looksee someday.
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
8,836
Gargantuan knowledge base to play effectively, sounds like a big PLUS to me! :)

It's interesting that Paradox games don't get reviewed poorly for their gargantuan and esoteric knowledge needed to effectively play those games. I think there's a double standard for RPGs. Reviewers think that they need to be auto-win on the hardest mode. I love what Owlcat has done and it stands head and shoulders above the rest because they took that chance to make their dream game, based on a true pen-and-paper implementation and one that doesn't hold your hand and does rival the other "gargantuan knowledge base" games. Long live Owlcat! :party:

Edit - And long live RTwP, my favorite combat system in RPGs. :nod:
 
Joined
Sep 5, 2018
Messages
1,603
Found some more reviews that give it an average score.

RPG Site - Score:6/10
I do want to make one thing clear - I enjoyed what I played of Kingmaker so much that losing a companion to a bugged status effect and many numerous resets of several hours of progress to circumvent poorly balanced kingdom mechanics wasn't enough to get me to shelve the game. Interesting companions, a unique framework, and a strong story were all enough to force me to keep going, to hope that I could somehow navigate the bugs, ignore the failed questlines I wanted to finish, and persevere through wonky balancing in an attempt to reach the game's conclusion, only to be stonewalled on the last lap. In 6 months or so, once the many numerous issues are dealt with both on a performance front as well as balance, this game could be amazing. But right now it's not, and sadly, it's not close.
Click to expand...
Trusted Reviews - Score:3/5
By committing to the systems it draws its name from, Kingmaker creates a deeply comprehensive and satisfying CRPG that is also incredibly lonely and masochistic when it wants to be.

If you fancy playing a painstakingly crafted virtual game of Dungeons & Dragons with HAL 9000 as your GM (and don’t get me wrong there are many of you out there), then this game is for you.

If not, you may enjoy the great voice acting and novel Barony system, but you should stick to more palatable CRPG’s that don’t assume so much knowledge and offer more than a modicum of respect for your free time.
Click to expand...
DarkStation - Score:3.5/5
Pathfinder: Kingmaker is definitely one of the most faithful recreations of the D&D experience in digital form and those with patience, a love of numbers and a willingness to tolerate a bit of opacity and imbalance have much to look forward to. There’s something a bit overwhelming and unfriendly about the game’s mechanics and while Pathfinder’s faithful translation of D&D and city building elements are unique, a lot of the setting, story and characters are a bit too “standard CRPG.” There is room for improvement and growth through patches and content, and it will be interesting to watch Pathfinder: Kingmaker evolve.
Click to expand...
 
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
36,351
Location
Spudlandia
Double standard again. Where are the complaints about Victoria II or Crusader Kings? Expectations taint these scores, taint them I say!
 
Joined
Sep 5, 2018
Messages
1,603
TheRealFluent said:
Double standard again. Where are the complaints about Victoria II or Crusader Kings? Expectations taint these scores, taint them I say!
Click to expand...
Yep and you all know my opinion on the Paradox DLC Pyramid Scheme.:biggrin:

The one silver lining is most reviews are average, and I barely see worse numbers. Still the publisher and private investors might not like it, but sale's are what matters.
 
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
36,351
Location
Spudlandia
Couchpotato said:
Yep and you all know my opinion on the Paradox DLC Pyramid Scheme.:biggrin:

The one silver lining is most reviews are average, and I barely see worse numbers. Still the publisher and private investors might not like it, but sale's are what matters.
Click to expand...

And it seems to be selling quite well with a good amount of people playing. Paradox's DLC is ridirkulous but I'm excited for Kingmaker's DLC. I hope it's one big expansion that adds mythic levels, or two medium sized ones that also add new companions. I was slightly disappointed at only 12 companions. I want like 20 in these games to choose from.
 
Joined
Sep 5, 2018
Messages
1,603
TheRealFluent said:
And it seems to be selling quite well with a good amount of people playing. Paradox's DLC is ridirkulous but I'm excited for Kingmaker's DLC. I hope it's one big expansion that adds mythic levels, or two medium sized ones that also add new companions. I was slightly disappointed at only 12 companions. I want like 20 in these games to choose from.
Click to expand...
Hmm are sales that good though as official numbers are hard to get?o_O

Anyway what I would like is more evil companions to help run my Kingdom, and quest with. Maybe some new content in future expansions also, if that's possible of course.

I would like them to optimize the game code in future patches also.:thanks:
 
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
36,351
Location
Spudlandia
Couchpotato said:
Hmm are sales that good though as official numbers are hard to get?o_O

Anyway what I would like is more evil companions to help run my Kingdom, and quest with. Maybe some new content in future expansions also, if that's possible of course.

I would like them to optimize the game code in future patches also.:thanks:
Click to expand...

More companions and advisors, evil or otherwise would be cool. With different strengths. I did find an evil priestess who wanted to be councilor to replace Tristian but I didn't recruit her. It does seem lacking on some evil advisors though.
 
Joined
Sep 5, 2018
Messages
1,603
Hotfix Patch 1.07 was also released today.

Hello everyone!Please, be aware that there are plot spoilers in the descriptions below (in the Quest, Areas and Kingdom sections)!

Quests

  • "The Seed of Sorrow" quest didn't progress after the evil dialogue choice in the Capital Asylum. Resolution: fixed.
Areas

  • Several encounters had the wrong enemies at Oleg's Trading Post become infused with First World energies (last chapter state). Resolution: fixed.
  • Incorrect copies of Mim and Dragn NPCs could be found in the capital. Resolution: fixed.
  • The encounter at Poacher’s Hideout could become unfinishable. Resolution: fixed.
  • One of the cutscenes got stuck if Tristian was wounded and had zero Hit Points at Vordakai Tomb. Resolution: fixed.
  • Trade with Dumra was not available during the "Deal with the Devil" quest. Resolution: fixed.
  • Party couldn't move at Rill-and-Spill area. Resolution: fixed.
  • Solo completion for the "Other World" area was not supported. Resolution: fixed.
Items

  • Some magical items could have issues with empty descriptions of their magical traits in the tooltips. Resolution: fixed.
User Interfaces

  • Days of the week could display incorrectly. Resolution: fixed.
  • There was no direct way to check the build version. Resolution: the build version has been added to the Main Menu.
  • The description for Enemy Difficulty settings didn't reveal all the mechanical elements altered by this option. Resolution: a more detailed description has been added for the Enemy Difficulty settings.
    Kingdom
  • It was unclear and confusing that after defeating the main threat of the chapter, all of the kingdom events associated with that threat remained active. Resolution: after defeating the main threat of the chapter, all of the kingdom events associated with that threat are removed from the barony. In case there are too many of such events, the kingdom is considered damaged and its development is slowed down. This state can be removed with special new barony project.
  • It was not always clear that some events can destroy the kingdom if not addressed. Resolution: a more detailed description added for the events that damage the kingdom and projects that remove these events.
Classes

  • Valerie's quest ability "Valorous" provided Strength and Constitution bonuses instead of Strength and Charisma. Resolution: "Valorous" ability provides Strength and Charisma, as per description.
  • Metamagic rods didn't work for sorcerers. Resolution: fixed.
  • Enemy Difficulty settings affected saving throws twice - the first time by increasing the enemy ability scores and the second time with a specific bonus to saving throws. Such implementation forced players to avoid spells with saving throws on the higher difficulties. Resolution: Saving throws are now affected by the Enemy Difficulty settings only once by increasing of base ability scores.
Miscellaneous

  • New pack of localization fixes.
System

  • Some players have persistent issues loading game saves that we were unable to reproduce so far. After analyzing possible threats that may cause this issue we implemented improvements that hopefully would fix the problem.
  • Some players complained about being thrown out of the game and to the Main Menu while entering the Throne Room (including the exit while trying to rest at the capital). Resolution: fixed.
 
Joined
Oct 1, 2010
Messages
36,351
Location
Spudlandia
I still haven't started yet. Planning to do so next weekend or so. Seems to still have a bunch of major issues, sadly, but I generally have a high tolerance for that sort of thing if the game is captivating.

It does sound like I should read up on the rules before I start though, despite most of it being rather similar to a system I know well (D&D 3.5).
 
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
7,586
Location
Bergen
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom