Finished with
The Last of Us Part 2.
Way too tired and emotionally drained to give a full blown review, so I'll leave it at a bullet-point list of my opinions on various subjects.
Graphics/Music/Atmosphere/World Building/Location Design:
- Absolutely top-notch. This has to be one of the best looking games I've ever played. And all locations are just fenomenal. And absolute blast to explore. That's one thing I could do forever in this game. Just explore every nook and cranny.
- Also, some of the abandoned/infested buildings/locations are just the most creepy I've seen by a long mile.
- The music is also pretty good, but somehow not as memorable as in Part 1. I was surprised the composer that did Mr. Robot also worked on this, alongside Gustavo Santaolalla, the composer from part 1.
- Sound design and sounds effects, also top-notch
Gameplay/Combat - very similar to Part 1, but quite a bit improved. Main characters move a whole lot smoother. Plus, I just love the addition of going prone, and being able to hide in grass. I abused the hell out of that one. I'm quite awful at aiming with controllers, so I had to make due with what I had.
Story/Narrative - this is the big contention point. The element that's most devisive about the game. Some like it, some love it, some hate it with a passion. The leaks that spoiled major plot points before the release also didn't help at all. The issue is, it is now very hard to differentiate who hates it because they've actually played it in full, and hate/dislike it. And who hates it because they absolutely oppose some of those spoiled plot points. The best thing you can do, I guess, is to try to take it all into full context, and try to be honest with yourself as to why/if you hate it. Personally, while the story is not perfect, I liked the idea it was going with. I liked the deconstruction of things that happened in Part 1. And while there are some plot points or decisions that characters make, that might not land perfectly, there are also some very very powerful moments. Either some rare moments of beauty, or more frequently moments of horror, dread, shock, fear, I guess everything on the negative spectrum? It was one hell of a ride, I must admit.
Another point about the story, and I'll end with this (as it seems, even though I began this post with the idea I would not write a wall of text, it somehow turned into that). I've heard opinions that they could have written a whole lot of other/better stories, with Joel and Ellie. And not this one. But personally, I've thought about that, and I'm not really sure where else they could have taken this story. The relationship between Joel and Ellie has pretty much reached full maturity, I would imagine, and I really don't see what else they could explore in that relationship, that would be equally interesting/impactful as this one. So, even if this isn't perfect, I think it's very good for what it was trying to do. It does have a couple of misteps, but most things arent't perfect. But I would agree, that overall, the story in Part 1 is a better one, and better implemented. But this one is so different, and ambitious, that I cannot not give it credit. In my opinion, whatever you think of the plot, it took balls of steel for them to take it in this direction. And I'd rather they take serious risks, and fail/not land perfectly, than to just phone it in with something too similar to Part 1.
Oh, another point to end on, I've also read complaints about some of the plot points that they are far fetched. That things happen too conveniently for the plot to go a certain direction. While I would agree with this, I find it hard to fault Part 2 for this, and not Part 1, which also had convenient plot points. I find it dubious to demand realistic/probable events in one, and not the other.
Anyways, that's it. I think I'd like for Part 2 to also get some expansion, like Part 1 did. But I'm not sure how many would buy it. But a man can dream. I'd love a "remastered" version for PS5 like they did for the PS4 version. And what I'd love even more, is for them to remake all graphics assets from Part 1, at the level of quality from Part 2, and run the first game in the same graphics/game engine. And then launch a full blown version for PS5, with both Parts included. Now that would be a dream.
EDIT: I found this
nice interview with the director, and two of the lead actors, and Druckmann goes into some details regarding some of the complaints. I like it. I recommend it if you have some time to kill.