1. Blackguards
2. Lords of Xulima
3. Drkensang: The River of Time
.
I haven't played Blackguards or Drakensang yet, but yeah I really enjoyed Xulima. I considered it for my top three. I thought the start and mid-game were really special and a great challenge, but the end-game got a bit weak - the area were you fight lots of demons got a bit tedious for me and dragged on a bit. It would definitely make my top ten though.