Your donations keep RPGWatch running!
Box Art

Gamasutra - The Designer's Notebook; No Twinkie Game Design

by Magerette, 2007-09-04 17:28:01

Gamasutra has an article up by Ernest Stuart concerning some of the more widely seen flaws in game design, or as he says "...a list of things not to do."  Here are a couple of examples:


The first time my wife sat down to the play the original text adventure, Colossal Cave, she saw the opening words:

You are standing at the end of a road before a small brick building. Around you is a forest. A small stream flows out of the building and down a gully.

Then it just sat there, waiting. "What am I supposed to do?" she asked the guy who was showing her the game. "Anything you want!" he said proudly (this was 1979, and games with parsers were brand new). But she didn't know what she wanted to do. The game didn't give her any incentive to do anything in particular, and we've lived with the same...Condition for nearly 30 years -- it still happens, believe it or not.

Moving on from game balancing to storytelling, Andrew Stuart writes about games that begin:

"You wake up in a strange place. You don't know who you are or how you got here. You have amnesia and your objective is to find out who you are and what you are doing here." It's hard to believe but it seems every second game has me waking up with amnesia. It's okay after a night out on the booze, but in every second computer game? Enough! 

The author also has a more comprehensive database of design mistakes unworthy of a twinkie reward on his own website, including:

  • Conceptual Non-Sequitars:Birds that Carry Swords
  • Bad Gameplay Design: Extreme Rule Changes when Fighting Boss Monsters, Puzzles Requiring Obscure Knowledge from Outside the Game
  • Bad Level Design: You Have 30 Seconds to Figure Out This Level Before You Die
 And many more.

Information about