That is a matter of opinion. It is, however, a fact that it does have elements typically associated with RPG's (and is much the better game for it).
There's an inspirational connection, yes. If you aren't arguing beyond this, then we agree.
I don't think anyone on this thread is disputing that.
But if it has more in common with traditional shooters then it can't be a runner-up for best action RPG. That was my initial statement.
Except that Half-Life 2 doesn't have the rich back story, complex and well-written characters, nor character development.
It does (Except character development). Here's your critique.
Last edited: