Geek.com likes Greedfall, too:
More information.Review: 'Greedfall' Is a Western RPG With Style
It's been a while since I've played a Western RPG I could sink my teeth into. This is mostly due to the fact that Bioware doesn't release these types of games with the frequency they once did. Thankfully, developer Spiders is here with an RPG that hearkens back to the glory days of Bioware with Greedfall. While it lacks the polish and AAA presentation of high-profile Western RPGs, Greedfall is an excellent game that fans of the genre will love.
[...]
I can safely say Greedfall caught me completely by surprise. While it contained a fair bit of bugs and glitches, they weren't enough to ruin my overall enjoyment. The combat system is robust and allows players a high degree of strategic planning. Each mission helps bring the world to life and players can complete them in a variety of ways. Greedfall is everything you could want from a Western RPG. It is an entertaining game that serves as a great base for future installments to build upon.