holeraw
V.G.A.
- Joined
- September 18, 2009
- Messages
- 693
It's about what is characteristic of the genre not about what is valid for you…It's valid if you require, as you said, that the character skills are more important than the human skills. I don't, so it's not valid for ME.
If all RPGs have skills (in one form or another) then they are part of it regardless of whether you use them or not.
Ehm, no, why would I?
Well… think of it like this: do you accept that every RPG game that you know of (and I understand that would be plenty) has character skills that have some impact on the gameplay? If yes then that should be part of the definition (if other genres have then too it makes no difference)
Probably we agree then… I just thought you meant that it wasn't really roleplaying.Yes, that's why I call it roleplaying. What's your point?
I suppose the people who placed those borders had a good enough reason... I couldn't tell. I think we can communicate well enough regardless though.I don't really feel competent to form an opinion about that. Strikes me as extremely restrictive, and again, pretty much useless in terms of communicating exactly what we mean by "Classical" music. A fine example of needless borders, once again.
- Joined
- Sep 18, 2009
- Messages
- 693