I won't claim they made a good business decision, but anyways, here's the excerpt from a Pete Hines interview.
https://metro.co.uk/2018/09/13/pete-hines-bethesda-interview-we-do-believe-in-single-player-7939215/
Maybe there's enough room for a lawyer to wiggle out of it. Works for me tho.
Well, that's 100% true for what they've done, so far.
All the content has been free, so far. As in, some of it you actually have to earn in-game - but you don't have to pay real money for it.
The upcoming Wastelanders expansion is a very good example of their generosity, I think.
I mean, that's like an entire game on top of the existing game - and they're giving it away for free.
To me, that's pretty fantastic.
But they're talking about game content, not "everything" they ever do for the game. Private servers is a feature, and not DLC content.
However, they DID promise private server access from the beginning - and regardless of whether they explicitly said it was free or not - I think that was clearly how most people would have interpreted it.
As such, I think they went too far by including it as a subscription-only feature.
Not exactly a deadly sin - just a poor PR decision, and one that doesn't sit well with me.
Honestly, I think they've had an amazing year in terms of content updates.
Again, vastly more free content than I've seen for any other live service game in memory.
Certainly more than I expected from this game.
But it's still Fallout 76 - and it's not for everyone.