Every one can rate something.
This is a subjective process, because most people have different tastes and preferences.
To be more objective in a rating process, the reviewer have to tell his audience what his tastes and preferences are and how he values them.
If he don't change his preferences over time, his audience gets a pretty good picture of every thing he rates.
Easy!
… and we don't need to discuss this every time when a new review comes in, because this is common sense.
1) Define your ideal game
2) Rate/measure a new game against your ideal game
3) Tell your audience about your ideal game and your rating of the new game
This is a subjective process, because most people have different tastes and preferences.
To be more objective in a rating process, the reviewer have to tell his audience what his tastes and preferences are and how he values them.
If he don't change his preferences over time, his audience gets a pretty good picture of every thing he rates.
Easy!
… and we don't need to discuss this every time when a new review comes in, because this is common sense.
1) Define your ideal game
2) Rate/measure a new game against your ideal game
3) Tell your audience about your ideal game and your rating of the new game