Top of the list would be Baldur's Gate I and II - I've lost count of the number of replays. Like some others in this thread, they are a constant install on my PC. I've also replayed Icewind Dale quite a lot, although I've only played Icewind Dale II once. Of the old Gold Box games, I still replay Pool of Radiance every now and again, although I haven't played the other games in the series for ages. For me, D&D games seem have a high likelihood of replay!
I also replayed Dragon Age: Origins quite a bit. With the silent protagonist and origin stories its easy to create a character that feels very different and has completely different motivations to a previous run. I had a particularly great time with an arrogant dwarven aristocrat character, which isn't normally the kind of character I'd roll…!
Of the newer games, I've replayed Might and Magic X, Legend of Grimrock, Tyranny (I can see that getting quite a few replays to be honest - its good fun trying different paths), Divinity Origin Sin 1 (I'll go back to this a third time at some point I imagine), and Dark Souls 1 (two runs so far, but I'm planning to try out the enhanced edition later in the year).
In terms of hours played, I'd add in some of the Bethesda titles like Skyrim etc, but I rarely replay those games with different character builds.
On the non-RPG side, there was a period in the late 90s when I was playing Quake and Streetfighter Alpha 2 pretty much non-stop.
I also replayed Dragon Age: Origins quite a bit. With the silent protagonist and origin stories its easy to create a character that feels very different and has completely different motivations to a previous run. I had a particularly great time with an arrogant dwarven aristocrat character, which isn't normally the kind of character I'd roll…!
Of the newer games, I've replayed Might and Magic X, Legend of Grimrock, Tyranny (I can see that getting quite a few replays to be honest - its good fun trying different paths), Divinity Origin Sin 1 (I'll go back to this a third time at some point I imagine), and Dark Souls 1 (two runs so far, but I'm planning to try out the enhanced edition later in the year).
In terms of hours played, I'd add in some of the Bethesda titles like Skyrim etc, but I rarely replay those games with different character builds.
On the non-RPG side, there was a period in the late 90s when I was playing Quake and Streetfighter Alpha 2 pretty much non-stop.