You want a fanboy? Here comes the …. Actually not.
To me PS:T is the best RPG I've ever played. I really liked the setting, the story, how TNO interacted with his history. And the dialogue, especially coming back to the same NPCs again and again with new dialogue options as the story evolved (reminds me of Ultima). I didn't mind all the reading. These things were more important than the weaknesses of the game.
It's the only game I was sad when finishing it, because I could no longer play it for the first time (similiar to how I felt after reading LOTR). That said, I haven't replayed it (I've never replayed a game - except tetris, solitaire and similar).
But I can certainly see that it's not everyone's cup of tea. No big deal, don't need to analyze why. Other people like games, even good games, I don't like. Notable example: Arcanum, which many consider a very good game. And I agree, but I still didn't like it, it didn't do anything for me.
BTW
sakichop. What do you mean by "death mechanic"? I haven't run into that expression before.
pibbur who thinks reading 500 000 words is twice as funny as reading 250 000. And who therefore wonders if he herafter should adopt a PST style when posting, but fears that it will take too much tiime. To write.