- So many different things to do.
- Great oldschool feel.
- You get to laugh. A lot. Sometimes unbelievably silly things happen
- So much true randomness.
- Modeling of things like water and weather and rotting and insanity make the game much more interesting.
- Each session is completely different.
- many details and small even insignificant things.
- very much complexity and challenge.
- never running out of things to do, never boring.
- No ending.
- No way to "beat" the game.
- Keyboard driven interface. (as you said earlier, it's great when you learn it)
- No "right" way to play it. Tons and tons of possibilities.
- You're never actually forced or railroaded to do something.
- the gameplay is so diverse and up to the player to such extent that it's almost like... expressing yourself or creating art.
- You can do and try stuff, even if it makes no sense whatsoever, you can do it. no artificial limits or rules to what you can or cannot do.
- Very refreshing to play a game that has been made so that the attention has been focused on creating a diverse, deep and complex game without spending all the time and effort on things like "how to make the game easy to play and learn" or "how to make the game look nice"
- And most of all: This game is the perfect antithesis of modern big budget multiplatform crap that most games released today are. All those things that I hate in modern games are done in opposite way with DF.
This stuff makes you feel so happy and makes you believe that as long as individuals can freely create software - great games can and will be made no matter what the big companies do or do not do. I have already started to get some vague thoughts about opening up my programming books and starting another game programming project.. I already have a finished game project (but very very simple) under my belt that I created with C++ and SDL few years back.
I don't usually like management games. I never understood "the sims" games (one of the most boring games I've ever played). Still, there's something in this game that makes it so special. TBH I don't even see it as a management/builder type of game. there's so much more.
If I'd have to compare it to a single commercially released game.. I'd say it's most like Evil Genius. Don't know if you played it but it has some similarities. but then again... it's nothing like DF
This game is a 5meg download. And I've had more fun with it than most of the 5gig games I've played recently.
Dwarf Fortress is an incredibly good game.