Now you're being subjective.
Don't worry, I'm not going to be dragged into a philosophical argument.
I certainly don't want to drag you into anything
But at least satisfy my curiosity, how was it subjective?
I said: "Regardless of your personal feelings"
Which isn't subjective as you made it clear what your personal feelings were.
I said: "DAO sold extremely well and did good on the market."
That isn't subjective as it is backed up by sales data.
I said: "That clearly indicates it was a "good" game by a large number of people"
Perhaps this is your quibble? I put "good" in quotes for a reason. I suppose, with some mental stretching, it could be considered subjective. But do you seriously think a large majority of people would buy a "bad" game? The reason I put "good" in quotes was to indicate the good aspect may be open to interpretation (subjective) as either GOOD being a lot of sales and hence it was "good" for EA/Bioware, or it was GOOD for players as why would a player buy a bad game, or both. To me it is less subjective and more objective. Selling a large quantity of games seems like a fairly objective way of saying a lot of people liked it and that it sold well so was also good for the company.
I said "even if you are not one of them. "
This was not subjective as you made it clear you were not one of them.
So I guess it was the whole "good" thing. Meh. I think it is pretty clear most people would consider the fact that the game did very well meant it was good for a lot of people and the company. It may not have been good for those who did not want to see the game do well or simply thought it wasn't a good game for whatever reason, but clearly it was good for many, as indicated by the sales and positive scores, reviews, and support it got. "Good" is a subjective term in and off itself but that doesn't mean it can't be used in an objective statement.
If I said "This is a good game" that is subjective. If we have 10 people and 8 of those people say "This is a good game" and 2 people say "This is a bad game" they are all subjective. But if I then say "most of the 10 people thought the game was good" then I am being objective buy stating a fact (even if the word good is usually a subjective word).