There are so many great games out there Lucky, really, so many. But the question is, what do you feel like playing? In the OP you mentioned 3 games, but don't really elaborate on what kind of game could tear you away from those 3 and when people mention games it turns out you've tried and played those as well.
I have a whole raft of games I could wax lyrical about, but there'd be little point if they're ones you've tried or ones that wont suit your personal taste. Can you think of a good way to describe what kind of game mood you're in and what kind of thing you're itching to play? With lots of micro-detail?